Given the problem of evil, I can understand that there are many ways one could interpret God as the villain of Christianity. In fact, many Western Christians who adhere to Penal Substitutionary Atonement already do. However, my question is this: in light of the fact that according to the Bible, Satan is the one who introduced death and mortality to humanity through causing us to eat from the tree, how can you say that he is a swell guy? Yes knowledge made it easier to alleviate suffering and death. But suffering and death wouldn't have existed in the first place were it not for Satan's deception. If you ask me, it seems like both God and Satan are equally bad and unpleasant. Neither would quite seem to be friends to the human race. In fact, read the book of Job and that precisely seems to be the case. The only loser in that story is humanity itself which is screwed over by both God and Satan in their cosmic bet. So yes, I could see why one would dislike God and see him as a villain, even if I disagree with it, but I cannot understand how one could portray Satan as being any better. He seems just as tyrannical and bent on screwing over humanity if it means getting back at God. In fact, I would say that the only time in the entire Bible that God becomes worship-able and things start to make sense is at the Incarnation. Were it not for God becoming man and suffering everything that we suffer in this life, I would not render him worship or honor.
English
-
If anything, Satan giving us mortality was probably one of the best things in religious history. If Eve hadn't eaten the fruit, God would have given us life and power, and as we all know, power is a bad thing to give to a sentient being. It was actually a shatter-point.
-
Giving power to a sinful being is bad, but we would have been sinless. Therefore our power would have been just and holy You see?
-
Here's a thought: why give us anything at all? Both sound pretty lousy. No one asked to exist. God's fault is in creating us against our will without the option to forfeit our existence and Satan's fault is in subjecting us to to death and mortality. I wouldn't say mortality was a good thing. It's just as bad in its own way in light of the millions of kids who die in Africa every year. It's trading one problem for another. A just being would give us the option to forfeit our existence if we so wish, instead of forcing us into a cosmic chess game like Jigsaw where both options seem pretty lousy.
-
I would say that both mortality and suffering are good things.