Honestly I feel that he should get his things back. I say that because I know that if i lost my stuff as well I would really really want Bungie to give it back to me. I'm sure 99% of u feel the same way as me but u won't admit it. Also he did this out of kindness. True he made a mistake but he was trying to help someone out and that person took advantage of the situation and messed him up. If we just keep saying "oh he shouldn't get his things back it will teach him a lesson and help him in the long run" , then the only lesson we are teaching him is to never help and trust any stranger. It's like the incident that happen a while back in china a men saved a womens life by pushing her out of the way of a car then she pressed charges against him for molestation. Couple of months later a baby was on the street and was repeatedly hit and missed by on coming traffic. The china citizens saw what was happening but none went to help because they knew that if they did help then something bad might happen to them. I know this situation isn't as serious as the china one but I wanted to make a reference to a past event. This is my opinion and IM NOT SAYING IM CORRECT. I just wanted to let some of u think about this situation is a different light. U may change ur mind u may not either way every individual is entitled to their own opinion.