My point was that you said if some non chicken thing layed an egg with a chicken, would it be a chicken. I said if I (not a tiger) had a baby tiger it would still be a tiger (even in the womb). Same logic applies, even if there's no eggs.
Also, frogs do lay eggs.
It's the physical egg itself that's important here. The egg is from the mother (a different creature) but contains a chicken. So what kind of egg is it?
Waitwaitwait. So this chicken egg doesn't look like a chicken egg?
So let's say a turtle layed it. It would look like a turtle egg... but have a chicken inside? Ming = blown
Let's just say it's both.
Yeah. Were talking about [u]chickens[/u] and eggs though, not dinosaurs and eggs. Though if you want to discuss whether the dinosaur or the egg came first, I'd be open to it.