GOTY, hands down as of all known games to come out this year. Absolutely amazing atmosphere (what I've come to know and love from Bioshock games). The ending was a bit of a mind-blam!-, no doubt about it, but you end up understanding it with time and thought. I guess that is what is putting so many people off about the ending. I'm going for 1999 mode very shortly, perhaps tomorrow. You can't understand how good it felt to play another Bioshock game after so long. The combat felt so good and fresh, even if it wasn't new. 10/10 for me, straight out without doubt. Best game I've played since ME3. And you think Songbird is badass now? Wait until the final act. ;)