Just got home from watching it:
[spoiler]
Pros:
Visuals
Amazing explosions and ship destruction, it felt like a Star Citizen tech demo
Well developed secondary characters
Cons:
Tarkin's CGI wuz baddddd
Killing all the main characters
Storm troopers still can't shoot straight unless they are hitting another storm trooper being used as a human shield
Some of the scenes where Jyn was making her climb to the top of the structure were boring and generic
[/spoiler]
Overall, good movie.
One question for lore buffs:
[spoiler]When the two storm troopers are chatting before being ambushed, one says "I heard they are finally replacing the T15's" What does this mean???[/spoiler]
T-15s are the ships Luke and Biggs would fly on Tattooinee.
I actually liked that everyone died and Tarkin. As for the Stormtroopers missing, "I am one with the Force. The Force is with me."
i believe t15's were the low speeder bikes seen in the original trilogy and i think its an allusion to star wars rebels, because in an episode the rebels sabotage a line of those speeders
[spoiler]could b wrong[/spoiler]