Like others I see both sides. I know this doesn't sit well on this forum but ultimately Bungie is a commercial organisation and there is only so much content they can dilute to attract new players. If Destiny 2 is a new 2/ 3 year lifespan game like now, then a fresh start would be the logical thing. I would like some carry over of grim score (not that mine is up to much) or possibly a light level boost for Destiny 1 players or incentive of some kind though. Personally, a game with the dlc options we have had with version 1 and a fresh start , is not something that has me wanting to break my disc though. Like others , splinters in awkward places.