I haven't bought any of the newer consoles yet, but do have access to them. I'll probably wait a year or so before purchasing one. As an RPG fan, especially JRPGs, there isn't much for me to play on them.
My PS3 is never off however, and I use my 360 from time to time. I also use PS Vita and 3DS a fair amount too.
I buy consoles depending upon their currently available software/games.
As for Wii U, I can only currently recommend Bayonetta 2, as you've mentioned. I personally am tired of 'Nintendo staples' and I never did like the Smash series.
Any recommendations for the Vita? I played the sh!t out of Persona 4 but now...
I just assumed the next gen systems would have had something by now and... I've mostly been playing my PS3 too. There's still a substantial back catalog of PS3 games I want to play.
That's too bad about the Wii U. I threw a lot of hours into Monster Hunter on the Wii but I had friends I was playing with.
I don't think there's anything left I haven't played on the 360 (but that's what I played the most last gen).
Most people don't like my recommendations but sure:
Demon Gaze
Sorcery Saga: Curse of the Great Curry God
Danganronpa
Phantom Breaker Battle Grounds
Disgaea 4
Senran Kagura: Shinobi Versus
Conception II
New Little King's Story
Freedom Wars
XBLAZE: Code Embryo
Soul Sacrifice
Grim Fandango
Ys: Memories of Celceta
Gravity Rush
Child of Light
Akiba's Trip
Atelier series
Hyperdimension Neptunia series
Mind Zero
Monster Monpiece
Muramasa Rebirth
Ragnarok Odyssey ACE
Rainbow Moon
Rollers of the Realm
Senran Kagura: Bon Appetit!
Tales of Hearts R
Velocity 2X
Virtue's Last Reward
I play a stupid amount of PSP games on it too. Such as Persona 1/2/3.
That's a sweet list! Thanks! Picked up Child of Light from the Sony sale and it's pretty cool (haven't gotten deep into it yet). Those all look like titles I'd enjoy. Copying and pasting into a Google Doc for research. :)