Check the article above. In short, the author thinks that presidents should not swear in on a Bible (nor any other religious text), but rather on a copy of the Constitution. Doing so would remove any sense of exclusion for non-Christians as well as demonstrate, as John Adams did, a stronger loyalty to the laws that one is being sword to uphold and defend, rather than a religious text.
Personally, I think this would be a step in the right direction, for all the reasons stated above. And I don't see how anyone could logically argue that we should continue using a Bible for any reason. It's an asinine tradition that should find itself in the dustbin of history.
What say you, Bungie.next?
-
9 回覆I don't care if they swear in on a copy of Popular Mechanics. I would just prefer that when they give their word, they actually keep it. The document doesn't matter. If the person taking the oath wants it to be a bible, the quran, or hustler, I don't care. We have freedom OF religion, not freedom FROM it. People's beliefs are supposed to be what they choose to believe, not what others TELL them to.
-
1 回覆
-
1 回覆Honestly, it doesn't matter It's as harmless as saying "one nation under God" in the pledge It's more of a symbolic thing rather than a religious thing In fact, it has nothing to do with religion It's just tradition But yeah I agree Although it's not a big deal, it would make more logical sense to swear on the constitution
-
2 回覆I have always been interested in this topic as a religious person. Jesus actually says that avoiding swears is best. Matthew 5:34-37 I always wonder why people still swear by the bible... (Shrugs)
-
3 回覆由Raw Sugar編輯: 11/20/2014 12:49:31 AM
-
2 回覆
-
1 回覆I'm not American, but I agree with this.What about when you have a non-religious president?
-
6 回覆I like the idea of swearing in on the Constitution, but I don't think they should be banned from swearing in on a piece of religious text if it appeals to them. It's a sign of honesty and standing by their word and holds them accountable to a higher power, which is kind of a big deal to some people. That being said, I know the amount of people who would absolutely flip if it were a Qur'an or the Book of Mormon would be disappointing.
-
1 回覆I can see your point. If I were somehow ever to become President, I'd probably use both. One on top of the other.