This is an FPS at its core so sorry to break it to u but its gonna be like other FPS. Gear only helps so much but when it comes down to it no matter what game u play Skill/Strategy > Guns/Abilities/Gear Every game in history has weapons or classes that are more commonly used so what do u want forced loadouts so every person on a team is using a different gun. Im not hating on ur opinion i am sharing a counter opinion. 95% of complaints about the crucible hold no weight in regards to balance it is simply just people complaining about better players out playing them. You basically complained that everything is OP but the fact of the matter is there will always be someone better that can beat u with any class gear or setup. Im not saying im one of them but i gurantee there are people out there where u could create them what u think is the worst class possible and u use the best one and u would still lose. There will always be better players.