I'm asking if you would care to explain why lxxTBonexxl is wrong instead of just saying that they're wrong and giving no evidence on your opinion. If you provide evidence, people will at least take into account your position on the matter, lxxTBonexxl provided reasons, so if you're saying that you believe differently, which you are, then you should also provide reasons.
P.s. sorry I took so long replying, I always forget to check