I personally think it's a bunch of bull. Please don't hate, I just want to know your opinions.
Edit 1: No, this is NOT bait. I genuinely want to know what others think.
Edit 2: I find all of this serious. Except the people raging that no is winning. I bust a gut every time I read one of those replies.
English
#Offtopic
-
8 RespuestasIf I think about it, people are born as infants. They are "blank slates" when it comes to their life and behavior where they can/do have genetic "predispositions" to be more or less inclined towards certain behaviors and that it is then the life experiences that occur as the individual grows that influence their responses and reactions to external situations and opportunities. An infant can have an inherited tendency (or a higher likelihood) of becoming chemically dependent, or a risk-taker, or a thrill seeker, or a being hesitant/shy, a high/low metabolism, be more likely to develop allergies, have a stronger immune system, all sorts of things that "lean" in one way or another as to what their later life will have them facing and dealing with as they grow and age. Do I believe that sexuality is genetically pre-determined? No, at least not completely. I believe that just like my genetics made it very likely (and eventually true) that I would lose the hair on my head, that some physical events are "more genetic" than some personal/social outcomes, that even those social outcomes are a matter of a genetic "nudge" that is then profoundly affected by life events, environment, and how the person grows and develops. The idea that sexuality is a genetic "pre-set" and there are no other factors involved doesn't seem (to me) to assign enough credit, power and influence to the individual, their environment, their life experiences, their environment and so on. But I am also not able to agree with the idea that "it's a choice". There are so many aspects of who each of us are as individuals that are not a matter of "I make the conscious decision to be ______" No one can make the choice to be smart, or tall, or athletic, or healthy, We are a sum of our genetics, our experiences, our memories, our conscious and non-conscious thoughts. Someone can make an effort to be kind, gentle, mean, rude, hostile, sarcastic, outgoing, withdrawn, and so on, but their conscious choice is only part of the process and choice alone does not determine if they are going to be what they want (or choose to be). Other factors can "make it happen" despite their conscious desires.
-
Does it really matter either way?
-
Editado por Tiber of Astora: 1/31/2015 9:54:18 PMScientists have proven it false through twin studies. The concept of homosexuality being genetic is baseless. That original hypothesis has been proven null. They believe that if it is from birth, that it could be related to hormones. I think it's BS. In Darwinian Science a species exists to perpetuate itself. If a gene were to prevent reproduction in a species, it would result in the eventual decline in that specie's population. Thus, the gene would be an evolutionary setback and would result in its eventual dissipation. Those with a gay gene would die off as a result of selection. Survival is paramount. Homosexuality is developed as a result of exposure and experience. The choice is in choosing to entertain specific thoughts when thinking critically. One thought builds upon another. By no means is homosexuality from birth. God, I wish I had the link to those case studies...
-
11 RespuestasYou're a Christian nut. Go kill yourself you sak of shit
-
The people who say yes are uneducated.
-
4 RespuestasI read that since identical aren't both gay if one of them is gay, there cannot be a "gay gene" Implying that people aren't born gay and that its not in their genetics to be gay
-
It is both biological and what a person is exposed to.
-
Don't like fat people?? Blame straight people for having gay babies
-
100% of gay people are attracted to the same sex
-
5 RespuestasI support gay 100% tho im not myself. But you cant really be born gay or straight. I mean you wouldnt understand either one. Its a choice one makes.
-
Editado por Pfhortnite: 1/31/2015 6:49:51 PMNurture endows what nature allows. Anyways, who even gives a shit? Does it matter whether they were born that way or chose to be that way? If you're gay, you're gay. It should just be accepted as that, just like it is if you are straight.
-
Is this a nature/nurture question? Or a "they choose" question?
-
It's just a choice ur friends and family say it so you respect them
-
No I don't think you are born with a specific sexuality but it's not a conscious choice either.
-
1 RespuestaEditado por Deus_Irae: 1/31/2015 6:12:16 PMYour not born gay, but its not a choice either, many of things that happen in your early life 5-10ish? can determine your sexuality. You have no control over it, and i believe that once your sexual orientation is set it cant be changed. For instance, If I was bi-sexual, I couldnt choose to completely like men because im also attracted to women. Rant over.
-
Yes, absolutely. Attraction is natural, they can't control. If you think they could control, then why do you think they would put themselves through all of the fear, hate, oppression, violence, etc.? The answer is they wouldn't. They are attracted to the same sex and nothing can change that.
-
14 RespuestasPeople are born gay. Its not a choice :)
-
I think all gays are born gay
-
6 RespuestasIf you're a Christian and you believe in original sin then you must believe that everyone is born with the capacity to commit any sin. If you don't believe in God and instead believe in evolution then homosexuality is a genetic abnormality that does not contribute to the continuation of the species. These are just two very simple arguments in this great debate. I'm not promoting either idea but it's fun to throw these out at parties and watch people rip each other apart.
-
Genetics and environment
-
Editado por Marear: 1/31/2015 4:48:04 PMYou're born with the set of genes, then the environment affects the expression. What's funny is the lack of education which allows people to conform to either side when they see slightest bit of support.
-
It's a choice. [spoiler]I bet I'll get 50 responses for that short, three-letter sentence ;)[/spoiler]
-
19 RespuestasNobody chooses to be gay. Ask any gay person.
-
18 RespuestasIts in genes so yes your born with it, there is even a way of telling by DNA test in the womb but it has been forbidden and banned for obvious reasons
-
No. You aren't born straight, gay or whatever. Your life experiences influence your preferences and eventually you come to a conclusion.
-
1 RespuestaI think it is a combination of both nurture and nature of varying combined levels for different people. Genomics is in its infancy, and from what I have gathered is, just because you have a marker for a disease doesn't mean you will always get that disease. It just means that your chances are higher. It also applies in reverse as well. Just because you have disease 'x' doesn't always mean you have a marker for it. Life has a lot of variables. To me it would seem silly just to chalk traits up to only biology without considering environmental factors.