{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Editado por Kestrel:
4/6/2020 10:00:38 AM
22
Lore Over Fanfiction
As interesting as your works are I can not hp but point out they are... not needed in this forum. Lore. History of our beloved game, that should be the main focus of the Lore Forum, to have questions and answers- not fan writes.
-
Not trying to be a dick but I cringe whenever I see another -blam!-ing fanfic post. It's really annoying.
-
8 RespuestasThese types of posts come and go. Unfortunately or fortunately (what ever side of the debate you lie on; personally I don't care, just let me make my lore posts), Bungie have said before that they won't be removing fanfics. I understand where you're coming from, and we've made attempts to make a balance when the fanfics get....out of hand. My advice is to either mute the fanfic tag, or mute the authors (I should say though, some of the authors do make their own lore posts, so it may serve a better interest to mute the fanfic tag).
-
Us writers agree, which is why we've been complaining to bungie to make a fanfiction specific page. This is the only place where they fit. Or rather, this is the place they fit best.
-
The entire sequel has been fanfiction especially when they literally started retconning lore from D1 and their excuse was everything of D1 was just folklore. Let the people have their fun. They're just doing the same thing Bungie is but sadly some of them are doing it way better.
-
There used to be a separate forum tab for fanfiction and other creative works, but Bungie got rid of it. But the reason why fanfic is posted in lore rather than another one of the tabs is because fanfiction is inspired by lore and the story of the game. Wether it be a fanfiction that follows all the rules and story set within the lore or a fanfiction that throws everything out the window to follow its own creative twists, they are all based upon the story of Destiny that the writers have come to love and be inspired by. The Lore tab is for all things pertaining to lore, not just questions and answers, but also theories and spinoff ideas (I’ve never seen anyone complain about people’s “make your own exotic” posts) So please, respect the creative work of every fanfic writer here as you would any other author or artist. No one asked for fanfic to be forced into #Lore, and no one asked to be ridiculed simply because they wanted to write something entertaining and share it with other people. If you’re not interested in fanfics, then don’t read them. There’s no need for you to downvote or make disrespectful comments or posts Your efforts would be better spent telling people to post clan recruitment in the Clan Recruitment forum instead of Lore, to post complaints and whining about the game in the Feedback or Gameplay forums instead of the Lore forum, and to post questions about game problems in the Help forum instead of the Lore forum. Those are all actual issues, unlike the current placement of fanfiction, but should be handled kindly by simply sharing a link to the proper forum with the poster
-
6 RespuestasI've muted about 98% of the degenerates, it's kept the Lore section nice and clean.
-
Unfortunately, the Ninjas' very creative interpretation of the rules says that fanfiction is in fact lore. They don't make the difference between established lore and made-up lore. Big mistake, but this topic will likely get locked soon. The best ones are those people who don't even tag their post as fanfic. Need some ego tuning, those ones.
-
Well bungie sure as hell ain’t making any good descions lately. At least fan fiction or lore from the players perspective is at least more thought out and detailed than what bungie does.
-
I just want to know Archival Mind’s opinion on fan fiction threads.
-
This is where I started my story, I’ve been here for years, I’m not leaving now. It’s not my fault everyone else wanted to start too.
-
1 RespuestaWhat bungie should do is add a fan zone that allows for fan art, fan fiction and fan concepts in the Forum.
-
10 RespuestasJust mute them. I’m up to at least 30+ people
-
1 RespuestaIDK. As long as it is clear in the post's title that it is fan fiction what's it matter?
-
9 Respuestas[quote]As interesting as your works are I can not hp but point out they are... not needed in this forum. Lore. History of our beloved game, that should be the main focus of the Lore Forum, to have questions and answers- not fan writes.[/quote] Take your Fanfiction to Ao3. ArchiveOfOurOwn
-
4 RespuestasI agree
-
Yeah id like to see more lore topics tbh.
-
-
It is frustrating
-
Yes I do believe we need a separate section for fan fictions on this app because I don’t want to have to use a different app or go onto a website. I actually thought at first that all of the fan fictions on here were extremely cringey but once I tried making a story I actually enjoyed it, so I hope that at some point there is a separate section where I can continue. Until then I will keep posting here.
-
I agree
-
2 Respuestas[quote]As interesting as your works are I can not hp but point out they are... not needed in this forum. Lore. History of our beloved game, that should be the main focus of the Lore Forum, to have questions and answers- not fan writes.[/quote] I know, it’s horrible right now, yet this is the only place that we have until Bungie gives us a part of the Forums to call our own. They only got rid of the old one because they said it was “not that active”.
