Uldren really set up the lore following Forsaken. "The line between the Light and the Dark is so very thin. Do you know which side you're on?" I love it. Shin Malphur's arc feels very believable and justifiable. His belief, that in order to reign victorious we must use both the Light and the Darkness, really sets the stage for some insane shit in the future.

My thoughts are I wish the story would show up in the game instead of virtual trading cards and ad hoc books.

he murdered people just we have in the game there is no right in that

callum just needs to get his ghost

Crispin Freeman voices him guys. CRISPIN. GODDAMN. FREEMAN. I better hear his voice again in the future, you can't replace one of the best voice actors in the industry.

I like Shin now, I hated him before he revealed his master plan to us. I simply just hate the blinded by rage type and especially the zealous type. It's why I hate the Praxic Order and Aunor. I was glad to hear that he actually isn't that blinded as to kill anyone that touches a dark artifact. EDIT: corrected wording.

I think he did what was necessary. Like The Drifter, he's from a time---post-Collapse----where the only law was the Law of The Jungle. Where people killed one another and simply took what they wanted/needed and kept going. And onto this landscape of chaos The Traveler dropped these essentially immortal beings with no idea who or what they were.....or what they should be doing. THEN you get one of them that becomes corrupted by the Darkness....and simply goes around killing anything in his path for the sheer sport of it. He doesn't kill to survive. He kills out of sheer pleasure...and occasionally sheer boredom. Like the Jedi, who see it as their responsibility to end those in their ranks that fall to the Dark Side of the Force, Shin saw it as his responsibility to put a stop to these corrupted Lightbearers....because none else could...and at the time nothing and no one esle could subdue them. So when it looked like one fo these Shadows of Yor were about to go down the path that Dredgen went....Malphur puts them down like the rabid dogs they are. Remember the scene where The Drifter gets the Haul from The Nine. One of his former "buddies" from the Shadows shows up....they sit down and play cards....and then the guy is ready to murder The Drifter in cold-blood because he's "fallen from the faith" (You're slippin'....you don't even use his name no more." ) So while his methods were the only method back then....there are other options. Less deadly options now....and Malphur seems to realize this. Which is why his methods seem to slowly be changing. He's willing to step back a bit and let the Praxic Order police renegade Guardians. He's willing to watch--for now---The Drifter. He's willing to take us into his trust. To the point he's willing to actually GIVE us Dredgens Yor's weapon....confident we will do what's right with it.

Look, originally I preferred the idea of Shin fighting against the shadows rather then leading them. BUT! What he did basically saved us from a war with ourselves before it even started sooooooo it works out imo. But I still preferred Shin before all this new stuff came out, the idea that he represented Light at its extreme was more interesting imo

I liked Shin more before the new lore came out. I'm personally tired of the whole "grey" theme.