First of all: why do you need every weapon in the game? If you really urge for hording stuff, go and collect Pokémon or Action figures or cars or stamps... What you and this guy are suggesting is getting rid of all the competitvness in the game. A lot of people play games BECAUSE of the competitvness and would go to play other games if there wouldn't be at least ONE mode that remotely resembles what they know from competitve ESport - getting feedback on how well you perform and seeing your skills improving and getting rewarded. Since we have no in-game league system, trials or leaderboards, the only motivation is the illusion of competitvness that comes with getting these pinnacle weapons. If you are devaluating them by making them free to all, you can be sure that your PvP population would quit to other games. (The Broadsword caused an enormous uproar and Bungie will never do that again). You could then continue to focus on hording stuff by mindlessly killing trash in the easy PvE content instead of improving your skills against real human opponents. PS: Since you mentioned caring about bad players "feelings" - A competitve mindset (that is required to succeed in any PvP game) requires to take all what it needs to achieve victory and not to care about others feelings if they lose. Also to value good performances of others and to learn from them and this is what the guy we are talking about clearly isn't understanding, observing his attitude and his loadouts.