One of you fine gentleman (or ladies) please explain to me -- what exactly was so "bad" about GoT season 8's writing? Seems like everyone and their dead grandma was unsatisfied and incredibly critical of the whole damn season. Why?
Am I just use to writers freestyling it when there's no more source material, after watching many an anime that caught up to its source?
English
#Offtopic
-
Editado por Uncanny_Vale: 5/25/2019 2:37:51 AMHonestly I didn’t think it was that bad. I might be wrong but the whole series (and books) felt like they didn’t really know where the story was going right up until the last few seasons. And then they were stuck trying to tie all the stories together into a coherent conclusion right at the end. The two things that were least satisfying for me was the speed of Daenerys conversion from good guy to bad guy. It needed more build up - it seemed to happen in one or two episodes and there was very little foreshadowing in previous seasons to suggest it would happen. The other thing that wasn’t that well done was the conclusion to the Night King story. The whole series was building up to this epic climax and it just petered out in one episode. I was really expecting more from that. I don’t think it was a bad ending overall though. They did the best they could with a fairly aimless and meandering plot (from the books) and a lot of threads that needed to be tied together. I think it could of benefited from maybe three or four more episodes. I don’t think six was enough to properly tell the story. Overall though I was pretty happy with how it ended.
-
Basically - it was too rushed. Which might sound like a minor thing, but when a story is rushed it negatively impacts every other aspect of that story. Major character arcs and events had no set up, there was no laying of breadcrumbs, there were instances of deus ex machina, characters teleported across the planet, characters seemed to make stupid decisions; but all of it was a result of rushed storytelling. GoT series 8 could have easily been another four episodes long, and if it had been, it probably would have been fantastic.
-
Editado por weirdboy99: 5/24/2019 10:14:17 AMIn short? They forgot character development. The story from S8 would be fine if they just spread it out over 2 complete seasons so that everything made more sense. Instead they rushed to the end. The writers were clearly done with the show and wanted to be done with it.
-
1 RespuestaI'd say that much of it just felt a little contrived, for one. Dany's descent into madness(?) is fine as a plot point, and there was certainly some solid setup (as the writers took great pains to point out) over the past seasons, but the way it happened just felt kind of rushed and unsatisfying. She went from feeling a bit lonely and isolated in episode 4 to full out mass murdering tyrant in episode 5. It was a bit jarring. Yes, she lost Missandei and Rhaegal in between, but the leap from that to blowing thousands of innocents to bits (and preparing to do the same to millions more) isn't a small one. There's Bran too, whose whole 3ER journey had basically no relevance to anything? Except for maybe contributing a bit to Dany's paranoia? And somehow he ends up on the throne because Tyrion says he has a great story, and all the important lords agree, I guess. His whole schtick has been that he's no longer of this world, that he's a man out of time, that he's no longer Bran etc, and now all of the sudden, with absolutely no setup whatsoever, he's placed in and gladly accepts the most temporal position imaginable, as "Bran the Broken". There are other more micro-level gripes, like how in the Battle of Winterfell, everybody was on the edge of getting overrun and dying... until they weren't, and Bran apparently just taking an unexplained joyride in his ravens, etc. That being said, I don't think the season was a disaster, and all the people crying and giving it 1/10s on IMDB are being stupid. It was fine, if ultimately unsatisfying, and even though much of it doesn't really stand up to much thought. Also, "The Bells" was visually stunning, and I greatly enjoyed it, deeper plot considerations aside.
-
2 Respuestas[url=https://mobile.twitter.com/DSilvermint/status/1125856091261136896] Here's a neat read[/url] because I'm too damned tired to words myself.
-
Editado por Clyde Beastwood: 5/24/2019 3:33:53 AMAfter all the character building, their arcs, their struggles, journeys, the build up to the inevitable, unstoppable White Walkers marching to Jon... all of that for the hollow shell that is season 8. Nothing about it was impactful like the seasons prior. It just felt rushed and mediocre compared to all of it before.
-
2 RespuestasIt broke years of character development. The characters weren't acting like they usually would and made dumb decisions and said dumb things. It was rushed.