Shin Malphur, The man with the Golden Gun or the man consumed by the hunt. Now this is something I wanted to do for awhile and I think we’re at a point where it’s actually pretty to think about this. Now I want everyone to try and keep their bias opinions out of this as I’ll provide a reason for each answer and you guys can decide from those two answers. (For the poll answer No he’s not consumed) Now Shin Malphur is a almost a mythical name itself. The man with the Golden Gun. Not just any gunslinger golden gun but, “The Golden Gun.” An insane title for a man with a righteous history. He’s the same who put an end to Dredgen Yor who was a menace to society and many innocent guardians and people and he hasn’t stopped from there. The Shadows of Yor are people who try and justify Dredgen as misunderstood and kill people on their own time whether good or bad. They are murders and crooks, but Shin Malphur endlessly hunts them down and tries to stop them at any turn. He’s a hero and a saint and without him who knows what could be happening. I mean look at it this way we know the Yors are bad look at CALLUM. The man kills and got so angry he killed his own Ghost. Who does that? And Shin Malphur efficiently stopped him from doing anymore harm. He sat in a Taken realm to stop this man for two whole weeks. That commitment. He is a man with a plan and he will not stop to his job is finished. (For the poll answer Yes he is consumed) Shin Malphur once a hero is blinded by his hunt. No man should be the Judge, The Jury, and The Executioner. That’s just to much power. This is the same man who came from a time period as the Drifter who really isn’t that different. Both have killed guardians, both in their own names are literal renegades, and both come from a time of Guardians being quite easily the biggest threat aside from the fallen. A time period of guardians killing guardians. He’s even teaming up with the Drifter who he doesn’t trust to find people who he feels by just watching their styles of attacking are on their path to darkness. Truly how can you get that much information from just watching a match of Gambit? Both sides wanna win so how does a Guardian who puts forth his most effort get determined. He invaded constantly to stop the enemy team from killing their primeval or did he just wanna kill guardians. You can’t tell unless you meet them. That’s why this Judge, Jury, and Executioner doesn’t work. Also he was in a Taken realm for two WEEKS. He had to have been corrupted some way? Sure it was to kill Callum, but the way he did it was to lustful. Blinded by lust he didn’t think and waited for Callum to speak before it was to late. Callum killed his ghost. Shin could’ve put a stop to it sooner and convinced his Ghost to not resurrect Callum and get all sorts of information of the Yors themselves, but he didn’t. He could’ve even had Callum locked up forever, but he didn’t. Why? Because he’s blinded by rage and revenge and that’s not what a guardian is about. Now you have had two different reasons both heavily bias. With these two and without your bias please choose and answer and surely discuss if you want to in the comments.