It's true that the best cards are in high demand and it can take a couple hundred dollars to create a deck that's the flavour of the month. However, simply having such a deck is no substitute for the skill that is required to know how the deck works, how it matches up with the other decks in the metagame, what your sideboard should be, when to sideboard, counting cards, all of that jazz. There's still a ton of skill involved, and while money is a big aspect of unlocking your abillity to do your best, it's like saying Nascar is play to win because your Average Joe doesn't have the money laying around to buy himself a racecar.
Not to mention there are other competitive ways of playing Magic that aren't as gated by money, like Sealed and Draft, these limited formats are great for adding to your card pool without the waste of just ripping open booster packs.
English
-
You make valid points, and it is based more on skill, but would you agree that you do need to put a good amount of money into your deck if you want a good chance of winning, especially if someone else is putting money into their deck and you are not...
-
Oh yeah man, I totally know the feeling, when the land base itself costs over $40 it makes me super sad :( Sometimes if you're super speculative you can get on top of the latest trends before they become a thing, for example, one of the biggest decks in standard lately have been Mono Blue devotion and Mono Black devotion, and a while before those things became all the rage I thought to myself "Damn, Nightveil Specter is only $2 a pop, and he triggers monoblue devotion or monoblack devotion so well! Maybe I should pick up a playset..." A week later, he jumps up to like $9 a price. If you stay ahead of the trends you can make yourself quite a bit of money, but unfortunately I don't have the time or the money to get invested :)
-
Same here I only do it as a social event with my best friends and some of them are putting money into their decks and I refuse to spend money... Logically, their decks will continue to improve while mine remains the same (I compiled a mono-blue defensive control deck, which is my style, out of their extra blues because blue wasn't taken and I like the concept of control). Eventually my deck will stand no chance against their improved decks and I will ultimately fail every time and our magic days will become less enjoyable for me... This is my situation...