[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] DavidJCobb [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] A Dumb Door The only problem would be in cases where the person killed may only have LOOKED guilty to the vigilante party. Then, the damage cannot be undone, an innocent life was ended. However, if the innocent party just had, say, a broken leg, then at least they can live to see another day.[/quote]So limit it to proven repeat offenses of the worst crimes -- raep, torture, and murder -- and require verification of identity prior to mandatory torture and execution.[/quote]In that case, maybe only allow for vigilante executions in cases where the offender is already known for doing a crime of the worst offense in the past, and if they are repeating it? That might work... Although it'd be a big risk on the part of the vigilante even still. They'd really need to have a lot of information, and really know who they're dealing with.