The major issue I have here is not the retirement. It’s the endless grind for shit perks and shit rolls. Give me a long grind to acquire precisely what I want, I’m ok with that. If I get it and don’t like the roll, I’ll grind for a week to get the gun with the roll I want. Essentially a weeklong quest for the gun/perk/roll of my choosing. Limit me to 1 gun/1 armor per week. I’m good with that. A mini-pinnacle grind. Make raid guns static rolls that are good. Bring back a fatebringer type gun a VoC gun. Make my grind meaningful. Make the perks good and you’ll keep me playing.

Ok Karen!

They always say they want to make things more meaningful but they are effectively doing the opposite...

I made a post about this [url=https://www.bungie.net/en/Forums/Post/255353746]here [/url]if you want to read the whole thing, but basically my criticism is that the current RNG of the game is too harsh to put a time limit on acquiring god rolls. If there is not a fundamental rework of loot in some way to accommodate the new system of rotating gear, unlucky people will not be able to get the weapons they want before they just become obsolete.

I have seen a lot of post against weapon retirement and I agree that it is a terrible idea. It undermines one of the core foundations of a looter shooter, loot will no longer matter. I have also seen a lot of the arguments for why this should happen or what you should do if you do not agree with the change, but the most important one is "Stop complaining and give a suggestion for a better system". Well here is the suggestion. My idea will not make either side completely happy but will give both what they want. First, loot retirement would happen. Second, at the end of the season the player would be able to select a number of weapons to be grandfathered into the new system, lets say five. These weapons would be able to be used in pinnacle activities and continue to be leveled up, all other weapons would remain frozen at the lower light levels. Last, at the end of the next season the player would be given the same option to retain a number of weapons for possible use in pinnacle activities. This would continue in this cycle. If Bungie believes that certain weapons are not eligible for grandfathering they could, but this information should be transparent from the beginning, no pinnacle/ritual weapons etc.... With this system both sides are happy, new loot matters to fell in those holes of the items that can no longer be used in pinnacle activities but I get to keep my Trust, yes one of the weapons I hold near and dear to my heart is the Trust, I really do not like or use any of the current pinnacle/ritual weapons. I will admit my idea is not perfect, but I feel it is better than Bungie's. It respects the player's time, money, and hard work that went into acquiring those old weapons.