JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

論壇

原先發佈於:The Ashen Conflux
1/14/2017 10:34:55 AM
8
The word you're looking for is fascist. New monarchy is a fascist party, not a communist one.
English

文章張貼語言:

 

以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • Feudalist. The clue is in the name "Monarchy"

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • It's not feudalist at all. Not every monarchy is feudalistic or do you see the brits working the fields for a bunch of nobles?

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • Modern Britain is a democracy with the queen as a head of state with no "real" power. The Monarch hasn't called the shots in Britain since Cromwell took over (although the Monarchs power started to dwindle after the signing of the manga carta). But before that when Britain was a feudalist society we were all out working in fields. Germany had a Monarch until (roughly) the end of WW1 they were "replaced" by a well known Facist. Fascism is (in general use) extreme right-wing, authoritarian, or intolerant views or practices. More like some other world "leaders" who may just be coming into power in a country with no Monarch in place (I'm referring to Trump if you hadn't guessed). But then you probably knew all that and were just trolling. Good job!

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • 由SeitePferd40編輯: 1/15/2017 8:41:40 AM
    Uuh friend. I hate to break it to ya but you really need to do your research a taaad bit better. The united kingdom is a constitutional monarchy and I do know everything you said, except that your basic thesis makes it all irrelevant. A monarchy can also be a democracy as you can witness in almost all modern nations that retained their kings/queens (let's not trigger anyone) mostly for representative reasons. Monarchies have been a political concept that has been around much much longer than the ~1000 years than the concept of Feudalism was around. I referred to NM as a fascist party because that's what it will most likely end up as, when a party basically smashes a parliament and installs an absolute leader with power over all. Often this process is accompanied by troubled and dangerous times for a people as is the case here. Just look at some European history and all the signs will be there. Also just to add a little something: After WW1 Germany first off became a Republic, with the more moderate ruling parties struggling to keep the more extreme left and right wing parties in check (Spartacus rebellion and Kapp Putsch), after showing signs of getting better (to no small part thanks to Gustav Stresemann) an economic crisis and fear of communism did Germany in...whereas the [url=http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law]-godwinslaw!-[/url] party didn't win the elections but came close enough for the elderly President of Germany to pick a certain Adolf Hitler as chancellor...and the rest is history.

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • Firstly, let me apologise. As someone who lives in the UK I am fully aware we are a constitutional monarchy. My error was in assuming you were younger/less informed so I "dumbed it down". My bad! Secondly; you refer to them as fascist because "that's how they'll end up" (paraphrasing). So you're calling them something now based on your opinion of how the future will go. Talk about an irrelevant argument. Lastly, I have a. sociology degree not a history one. I tip my hat to your historical knowledge. I do however maintain you are still completely wrong in calling NM either a communist or fascist party.

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • Thank you very much. But eitherway I was mostly jokingly referring to New Monarchy as a fascist party, as the op first of all referred to them as a communist party in his attempt to make the fwc appealing. So in that spirit I called them fascist as calling them communist would just be absurd. But eitherway you're rightfully pointing out that the criteria I used are not sufficient to call a political group fascist.

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • Wow. This has been a genuine pleasure. A sensible debate on Destiny forums where no one has resorted to name calling. You sir/madam (not assuming gender) are a star. I tip my cap to thee.

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

  • No woman would be that educated on a political system. Of course it's a man

    文章張貼語言:

     

    以禮待人。發佈文章前請花點時間查看我們的行為準則 取消 編輯 創立火力戰隊 文章

你無權檢閱此內容
;
preload icon
preload icon
preload icon