Think about this: if you murder a murderer, you still go to jail. Breaking the rules to identify someone breaking the rules still means you broke the rules, and will face punishment.
Also, on the other side, while YOU may not post someone here unless they are without a doubt cheating, you are not the majority sadly. False reporting is such a big issue due to people thinking someone is cheating because they are losing to them. So they come here, falsely (and publicly) accuse the person of cheating. Then a bunch of people jump in here and start doing the same thing to this person (or more since the original namer doesn’t have control over others actions) leading to a witch hunt of a potentially innocent person.
Imagine if someone accused you of cheating here and enough people agreed that they started harassing you or you were banned. Is that fair, especially if you were innocent?
The name and shame policy is there for the protection of innocent people from other people. Yes it also means you can’t call out blatant cheaters as seen in some videos, but that’s what the report player section is for. If only people would stop reporting everyone for everything and only reporting people that are without a doubt cheating (like that dude in frost bolts video lol).....
English
-
Thats why I think there needs to be an amendment. If you break the rules now then you broke the rules, but just because its a rule doesent mean it isent a bad rule. If you are getting accused of cheating by parts of the community without proof then why would Bungie ban you? Bungie bans after finding evidence, not because one person said it and 100 more jumped on the band wagon. Your murdering a murder is a good analogy but only works but only halfway. If you murder a murderer you are still being held against the same rules as they are. But for bungie to have separate rules in two different areas while one rule defends someone in the other area. That would be like a murderer killing in another state but being protected by another state bc the rules are different. Thats why Im not saying open the flood gates to report cheaters with the current forum tools, but have a more professional forum area where reports could be made that the community and bungie can both see and post.