John is absolutely my favorite so far. Yea just flat out nuts, "I looked for more and more ways to say YES", dealing with him was just unsettling. [spoiler]Dude and the moment you realize that shit he's stapling to his board is human skin he's flayed off people. Damn.[/spoiler] My least favorite and this probably won't change is Faith. Her story is whatever, I didn't really like all the Bliss bs, it was kinda just tedious. But my biggest gripe is that her story line is just so unfulfilling. [spoiler]I wanted to kill the shit out of her, I hated her way -blam!-ing more than John. The fact you don't even get to kill her is just wack. I didn't feel like I won, I felt she got to go out on her own terms and she even got the last word in, i honestly feel like she kinda won even though she died. It would have been so much more satisfying to just -blam!-ing shoot her in the middle of her final speech. Like "shut up bitch, we're done listing to you". But no she finishes her speech and just lies in the water dead. I get that she was already dead and that was all in our head, at least I think, but it was just not a satisfying conclusion for me. [/spoiler] Bout to take on Jacob, I'm looking forward to that. So far I'm loving the game.

Faith. Unlike with the brothers, she is less overtly malicious and hostile. It is easy to hate and vilify someone that is an obvious asshole...with her, it was much more subversive... which makes it that much more... psychologically damaging