JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

자유 게시판

자유롭게 대화를 나누어보세요.
8/12/2014 11:13:02 AM
270

A "test" for atheists

Put aside all the arguments and all the debates you've had before. This is where it really matters. If you really believe in atheism then I want you to prove that God is not real. That's it. That's all I ask for. Simply prove that God does not exist and we will stop bickering over the matter. Can you do that atheists? Can you actually support your claim that you defend so vigorously?
English
#Offtopic

게시물 작성 언어:

 

다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

  • And thus the world turned to ash

    게시물 작성 언어:

     

    다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

  • nice b8 m8

    게시물 작성 언어:

     

    다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

  • [quote]Put aside all the arguments and all the debates you've had before. This is where it really matters. If you really believe in atheism then I want you to prove that God is not real. That's it. That's all I ask for. Simply prove that God does not exist and we will stop bickering over the matter. Can you do that atheists? Can you actually support your claim that you defend so vigorously?[/quote] You are completely ignorant. "This is where it really matters", what is "it" and why does it matter here of all places? I don't think you understand what Atheism is. Also I don't think you understand logic. And I don't think you understand the controversy about this topic. I'm gunna go out on limb and say that you follow Christianity. Besides that being a highly popular religion, and Christians are the only people I have seen try to argue about this. First of all, science [b]never[/b] went knocking on the doors of the church, saying "down with God! Down with Jesus and his disciples!" Never has that collectively been the goal of scientists who are Atheists. Which is currently 93% of the elite scientists in the world... I don't need to provide evidence for saying that, it's a well known number, if you don't believe me, look it up. As science has progressed, yes it might have interfered with some of the explanation and understanding that the bible brought, but it [b]never[/b] once attempted to break down [u]faith[/u]. However, the Christain church has done an excellent job at stunting scientific progress and ideology since the times of Galileo and before. (Another thing I don't feel the need to provide evidence for, once again look it up if you feel the need to dissent) So, when you ask us to reason our disbelief to stop your bickering, when all this does is have the Christain community bicker [b]more[/b], you look like a jackass. It's a completely ignorant subject to argue about by the way. Secondly, you speak of Atheism as a religion. Stop that. It is not a religion of any sort. Quite the opposite actually. I do not believe in Atheism; I do not believe or accept any [u]religious[/u] body or system of beliefs, therefor I am an Atheist. Atheism is the rejection of religion. So since it is not a religion, how do you expect to ask all these people, who all may or may not have different thinking, to answer a question collectively? You can't, unless you are conducting science, where you can answer a question collectively by using empirical evidence and understanding of natural phenomena, which is why many Atheists tend to be scientifically literate. (NOT saying Christians aren't, NOT saying all Atheists are) Thirdly, let me explain why it is completely illogical for you to ask me to disprove God to you. Let's begin with the fact that you have faith in God, so we can also infer that by making this thread, you in no way shape or form intended to be proven wrong. Otherwise, you would not be so defensive if you were considering the possibility of the non existence of a deity. Now let's move on to the fact that the argument itself between Christians and Atheists is a complete logical fallacy. Your God [b]cannot[/b] [u]currently[/u] be proven in any way, shape or form. Our Big Bang theory [b]cannot[/b] [u]currently[/u] be considered fact in any way, shape or form. If you notice those statements are very similar, and very true, but as it stands the Big Bang one is different. Why? Because it is a scientific theory, and to the scientific community, it is true until proven false. [b]THIS DOES NOT INTERFERE WITH FAITH, HOWEVER IT DOES INTERFERE WITH RELIGIOUS CONCEPTS EXPLAINING THE BEGINNING OF EXISTENCE, WRITTEN AT A TIME WHERE WE WERE SCIENTIFICALLY RETARDED COMPARED TO NOW.[/b] Nonetheless, your God can never be disproven, which what you have to realize, is not the dream of an Atheist to disprove God to people, I don't know why Christians are so scared of the concept of people disbelieving, that they have to go out and argue their point using theology. Look, buddy, there's no way to prove either side. However until the point comes that people fully accept that science and religion are two separate things, until people stop bickering about how we need religion in the science class room, or that we can't teach things absolutely fundamental to modern science, until that day comes, Atheists will always defend science. Do not provoke them of you plan to get into this argument, because you will look like a dumbass.

    게시물 작성 언어:

     

    다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

  • Neither side can "prove" anything. There is only faith and doubt respectively. There is no point in creating conflict over something that neither side will ever agree over.

    게시물 작성 언어:

     

    다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

  • Can Christians, Jews, Hindus, or Muslims support their claims that there [i]are[/i] gods out there? No? Well then.

    게시물 작성 언어:

     

    다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

    3 답변
    • Ok show me proof that he is real other then a book written over 2000 years ago. Show me a video of someone meeting him. I can ask you to prove to me that he is real. You have a question that can go both ways if you arnt willing to answer it for yourself dont ask.

      게시물 작성 언어:

       

      다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

    • Religion is what creates war. That's all.

      게시물 작성 언어:

       

      다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

    • that kid meditated for around 10 months.... no food no water..... alive today... not science.. also black holes were wrong.... science also coffee is now bad for you again... science also long term space missions not possible once again ( in theory ) .... science also cured ebola with that first scientist to come back from africa..... no on else gets cure........science cant remember how to make roman flamethrower...... thanks science also science was alchemy at one point.......grey wolf ( look it up) ......( philosophers stone not real) ...science also cured rabies once.... wont do it again...... science science is wrong so much... and if it isnt wrong now than it will be in 2 years.... science, making shit up since back in da day........ science is a riligion of people trying to cover each others asses and making money.. lolz

      게시물 작성 언어:

       

      다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

      1 답변
      • I'm an apatheist. I don't care whether or not there is a god. I don't have the time to think about if there is one or not and I believe it will be many more years before we are capable of discerning whether or not there is a god. We cannot conclusively say whether or not god exists. If you told someone 100 years ago about the Internet and Quantum physics, they would think you were a mad man. If you went back another 100 years and told them that man will walk on the moon, they will say that you're a lunatic. We are no different, our understanding of the universe and of science, compared to what we will know in 100 years, will be worth nothing and people will look back and wonder how we were so ignorant. Tldr: I don't know what to think of God and I don't know whether or not he exists. I do know that I am wasting my time by arguing for either side as I cannot conclusively know the answer and would end up contributing nothing.

        게시물 작성 언어:

         

        다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

      • 작성자: DWNWITDABRN 10/16/2014 6:44:53 AM
        It is saddening how fellow atheists, who almost by definition should be logic driven, can write such thoughtless comments. I am personally an atheist and a Physics major. I can tell you that nobody - no matter how smart - can either prove or disprove the existence of any god. My wife is catholic, and yet we have absolutely no issue between ourselves even though we are completely engulfed in each other's ideologies. Just accept that people will believe what they want, and that no amount of reasoning, science or bible verse will change their minds. Such a simple thing that seems lost on people. So shut your faces, and play the damn game. This is a game forum by the way.

        게시물 작성 언어:

         

        다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

        2 답변
        • It is unnecessary to disprove that which has never been proven, otherwise you must assume all deities have to be real.

          게시물 작성 언어:

           

          다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

        • 작성자: BantZuluLeTurkey 10/16/2014 8:25:00 AM
          OP, I'm a Spiritualist here, I'd like you to prove to me that there is only one God. That's it. That's all I ask. Show me the irrefutable evidence that there is only one God in existence. Edit: wow who the hell necro'd this shit.

          게시물 작성 언어:

           

          다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

        • what if god is science, is god science or is science god...

          게시물 작성 언어:

           

          다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

        • Prove that Santa isn't real first.

          게시물 작성 언어:

           

          다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

          1 답변
          • I am an Atheist, I don't care what you believe in but I get very pissed off when other people just straight out say "my religion is right", you are claiming my belief is illogical because I can't prove yours wrong. You are either a troll or just stupid.

            게시물 작성 언어:

             

            다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

          • Can you prove that god exists.... Can you prove the claim you defend so vigorously

            게시물 작성 언어:

             

            다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

            1 답변
            • Counter proposal. Prove God is real.

              게시물 작성 언어:

               

              다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

            • Can we stop? Why does the flood obsess over religion like this? I'm not even an atheist, but I am sure the atheists here would appreciate being left alone.

              게시물 작성 언어:

               

              다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              1 답변
              • Haha proving gods existence is futile. Doesn't mean it isn't existant though ;)

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • That's like me asking you to prove god is real lol

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • The gods or God of man made faiths are fairy tales to lead and inspire gone awry. Grab a physics textbook, research quantum mechanics, study psychology, read up on astrophysics while you're at it, then finally take a simple biology course. Tell me then if you still believe what you hear. Everything we are is a lie.

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • [quote]Put aside all the arguments and all the debates you've had before. This is where it really matters. If you really believe in atheism then I want you to prove that God is not real. That's it. That's all I ask for. Simply prove that God does not exist and we will stop bickering over the matter. Can you do that atheists? [b][i][u]Can you actually support your claim that you defend so vigorously?[/u][/i][/b][/quote] Lel.

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • God is dead Ozzy said so

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • You can't prove god is real or fake.

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • Can you prove god is real? Do that for me. Have fun talking to your imaginary idol.

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              • Can you prove he exists?

                게시물 작성 언어:

                 

                다른 사용자들을 존중해주세요. 게시물을 제출하기 전에 한 숨 돌리고 운영 정책을 검토하세요. 취소 수정 화력팀 생성하기 게시

              1 2 3 4 5 6 7
              회원님은 해당 콘텐츠를 볼 수 없습니다.
              ;
              preload icon
              preload icon
              preload icon