{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
12/21/2016 6:03:43 PM
26
So an interesting thought to open up discussion.
Ok, so we have Native American Tribesman. The varying and vast cultures that each tribe represents. The majority of which that have been assimilated or lost to time over the past 400 years.
At which point did we as Europeans become, Native Americans? Liberals like to attack whites lately for genocide, land stealing, ect ect... Yet we have been a nation for over 200 years. Are we not all now, Native Americans.
By definition we are natives;
na·tive
ˈnādiv/
noun
1.
a person born in a specified place or associated with a place by birth, whether subsequently resident there or not.
Are we not ourselves after a few generations native Americans ourselves?
If we use logic, reason, and facts. Yes we are all native Americans.
I am personally of actual native heritage, Black foot, and chippewa to be clear.
However my family stopped taking part in tribal affairs a century ago.
I by no means condone the genocide that took place.
I simply am tired of people holding the current generation hostage for things that occurred 250 years ago.
Discuss.
English
#Offtopic
-
We are, by that definition you gave, a native of the United States. However, those born in America with no ancestry in a Native American bloodline (Apache, Iroquois, Seminole, etc) are of a different definition (this may be a bad explanation. We'll just say little "n" and big "N". Honestly, we should just stop using the term "Native American" and begin to use the correct tribal names for the peoples being described. But, I do see the point of using "Native American" when talking about the groups of people who migrated to America as a whole.
-
6 답변The genocide never ended. Today we suffer from the genocide of thought: the genocide that kills genders and identities, relegating the infinite variety of the human soul down to two, infinitely oppressive pronouns. We live in a age where male, patriarchal oppression has reached Orwellian proportions, where only the few, the white, and the fat (rich) have a voice. The man this country has elected is worse than Hitler in every way, shape, and form. You think 200 years ago doesn't matter? Ask yourself that when gays and other gender identities find themselves cordoned off from the rest of society. Ask yourself if it matters when the wage gap widens again to epic proportions. This last election represented nothing less than a cosmic struggle for human justice and equality, a battle that reason and decency lost. For those of us with a different skin, identity, or political voice: we are all the natives now. And the pure drum beat of our heritage is is becoming distant, overwhelmed by the strident march of the pateiarchy's calvary...
-
작성자: genericuser81 12/23/2016 3:41:11 PMThat is a very narrow definition of native, add this to it [quote](of a plant or animal) of indigenous origin or growth[/quote] And that means no, you aren't native after a couple of generations. I do agree that people need to get over the past and people (native American, African American, Australian aboriginal for example but obviously not limited too) need to stop using historical injustices as an excuse.
-
2 답변It isn't fair that we are held accountable but think we aren't helping them much. In Canada here they are basically second class citizens. This is left over from things we've done to them in the past. That includes the residential schools that caused many to die and have major problems like alcoholism and drug abuse. That has no good effects in any community. We give them land they want. But we don't care enough to give them adequate support. Take Attawapiskat for an example. It is in the far north of Ontario, pretty remote. People there are living in third world conditions, in a first world country! How messes up is that? It's not enough to apologize for the wrong doings of the past, we have to help them thrive, give them the opportunity to not be living in poverty. Anyways that's my take from a Canadian perspective. Thanks
-
작성자: JTAssassins 12/22/2016 3:14:58 AMIs your life really affected. Do you really feel like you're being held hostage...[i]really[/i]. Yes we every native born American are native, obviously. But ignoring the issues that [i]native Americans [/i] face are still relevant today. Pretending lile everything is fine just because time has passed is a problem . So if you're point is really "when are they going to get over it" there're not if they are still affected by it
-
2 답변
-
1 답변I simply am tired of people holding the current generation hostage for things that occurred 250 years ago. Well said....this could be said of a lot of things that need to be remembered but moved on from.
-
2 답변Nope. You forget, a NATIVE AMERICAN is a race and an ethnic origin. We are also known as Aboriginals. You are NATIVE TO YOUR LAND but you're not NATIVE AMERICAN. [i]*resumes with chillin' like strawberry fillin'*[/i]
-
5 답변Unfortunately native american is also a race. So you are asking something similar to "at what point are we all black?" True, generational grudges are annoying but if you do nothing to ensure there are no laws that allow things like -blam!- to be perfectly legal on reservations (there is a loophole like that in the states) or are other wise racist/oppressive, then you are still to blame.
-
Technically yes you could say that. However you could also argue that "Native American" refers to the race whose heritage is native to America. If that's the case, then technically there is no such thing as a Native American, as Caucasians migrated from Europe, and the "Native Americans" migrated from Russia via the ice bridge between Alaska and Siberia. All that said, colloquially, it makes more sense to just keep the labeling the way it is. There's no need to nitpick the language as long as everyone can understand what you're talking about.
-
5 답변Funny thing about how that works. See there are other people that were here just as long. Yet they are currently being targeted by the ICE Want to take a wild guess?
-
3 답변Native Americans have been mislabelled ever since white Europeans discovered them .They called them Indians for some reason instead of calling them by there nation. Apache etc.
-
2 답변
-
3 답변The first child born to European immigrants here was a native American. We are all native Americans, unless we immigrate from a different country. [spoiler]case closed.[/spoiler]
-
1 답변
