Since I've made all 3 and have taken them all into crucible... I can't hate on any of them. They all are pretty good and fairly balanced. Blade dancer is op? You'd be surprised how difficult it is to actually get multiple kills. Try it out and you'll understand. I'm talking like 4+ kills lol. Golden Gun is op? I've missed so many shots. Four shot helm a must, even so you can still be killed easily. You miss a shot or two and you might as well just sit down. Timer runs fast too. Novabomb is op? Throwing it down at a group that's half expecting a super is instant death. Unless you have the helm of ahamakara or whatever. It's hard to line up good shots, or you miss it because you hit the ceiling/ledge/pipe right above/next to you. Sunsinger is op? Besides fireborn, which is almost pointless in crucible as you die almost right away. Throwing grenades isn't too life threatening, less firebolt and burn damage is on. slapping people to death requires you to be upfront and center which can mean a shotgun to your face. It's prolly netted me the least amount of kills out of any super. Fist of havoc is op? This ones fun to use and can be irritating to get the hang of. Unless you're running around the corner or catching your opponents off guard- you're not gunna be successful. I've died so many times just trying to get in range for a fist of havoc it's stupid. Defender is op? If you step in the bubble you're stupid. Just run away and go elsewhere. Can't kill you if you're on the other end of the map. lol