I personally enjoyed it more. Thematically it was more interesting to me, the tonic was a cool idea (but should simply not work in PvP and endgame PvE), and it didn’t validate the pointless fighting between classes. If Revelry had Rushdown and a tonic-allowed PvP mode, it’d simply be better than Guardian Games. But part of that is just me liking the aesthetic and vibe more (and despising the senseless class wars GG sparks every year) which is a completely subjective thing.