Hey guys, thanks for the help.
I noticed some of you said that toothpaste would work. So, I tried the plain, non-whitening particle stuff and it ended up getting tons of scratches. I have a warranty on it, and will get it replaced this Sunday.
Hey, at least I know first-hand that toothpaste doesn't work on disk scratches.
Thanks, crwnandginger
Get it shrink wrapped and take it to the store. They may take it for full refund, or allow you to exchange.
Office Depot does shrink wrapping for mere pennies!