Hey guys, thanks for the help.
I noticed some of you said that toothpaste would work. So, I tried the plain, non-whitening particle stuff and it ended up getting tons of scratches. I have a warranty on it, and will get it replaced this Sunday.
Hey, at least I know first-hand that toothpaste doesn't work on disk scratches.
Thanks, crwnandginger
If there's any game stores around that aren't gamestop, most places will resurface your disc for +/- $3. There's a family video right down the road from me that hooks me up and does it for free.