JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

Destiny 2

Discussioni su Destiny 2.
3/20/2023 10:16:04 PM
27

Commendations - We need to Talk...Guardian Ranks, I'll get to you in a minute

Issues this feedback addresses - Commendations feel hollow - Commendations feel like too much of a grind - Commendations don't accurately capture who I am as a guardian - Commendations are convoluted and I have no idea what I am handing out --- FEEDBACK Commendations are now AUTOMATIC and are untethered from guardian ranks. Guardian Ranks should only require feats (including PVP, yes I said it). Commendations fall into one of three color coded categories - Blue/Legend of Zavala (objective based accolades: most zones captured) - Red/Legend of Ikorra (damage based: most kills, most damage) - Green/Legend of Cayde (life of the party stats: most assists, revives) Lastly, auto commendations will also unlock one skin/shader after a player has reached the required threshold. Players also get access to one manual commendation at the end of an activity per player. Manual commendations fall into the same three color codes: - Blue/Legend of Zavala - Given to guardians who exemplified leadership - Red/Legend of Ikorra - Given to guardians who exemplified exceptional battle skill - Green/Legend of Cayde - Given to guardians who exemplified high fashion (lol) or humor Manual commendations do not give points, but instead can dictate what color a guardians rank (6) is above their heads. Players will be able to choose whether they want their automatic commendation color to show or their manual commendation color to show. Anyways - just some thoughts! Be safe out there Guardians!

Lingua:

 

Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

  • Ho boy do I agree with this. Commendations is half baked at best, and it’s tied to Guardian Ranks, which is insanely frustrating. 2 commendations to give out with Gambit and Crucible? Ok so now let me check the screen to see how everyone scored. Whoops, took too much time, now I can’t hand anything out. I’ll try again. Next round over, it’ll gotta do this quicker. Oh, thoughtful and joy filled? I mean they killed other enemies, not sure how I can mark someone as thoughtful. It’s thoughtful of them to kill enemies so they don’t kill me. But then that always happens, so it’s always thoughtful for everyone. Ok now I gotta hand out…..2? But there’s 5 others in this crucible match? Long story short, why was this system put in place to begin with in such a state that it makes it almost unusable? Did no one have a round table talk about this and actually go through what works and what doesn’t before implementing it? I’m just beside myself with it. And then to tie it to Guardian Ranks? Who thought of that?!?!? My god….and I’ve never been overly critical of this game. I’ve loved it from the beginning. But what’s been given, guys have more meetings please.

    Lingua:

     

    Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

    1 Rispondi
    • Modificato da waterpolo1: 3/21/2023 12:51:20 AM
      Commendations should be untethered from Guardian Ranks. Good idea. Commendations should dictate the color of your guardian rank. Good idea. Commendations should not be given out automatically. I don't like this. If you were selfish or a jerk, nothing for you. Let's keep them all manual. To add to your post. Let us give out commendations within the "last played match" tab in cases where the post game commendation screen does not load.

      Lingua:

       

      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

      4 Risposte
      • Commendations and ranks are useless.

        Lingua:

         

        Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

        1 Rispondi
        • I think Bungie could have saved resources on the game by not implementing Guardian Ranks and commendations. But it seems they’re really trying to push that “everyone’s a special snowflake” mentality and giving everyone participation trophies. But even that’s kinda wrong since people can skip awarding others commendations.

          Lingua:

           

          Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

          1 Rispondi
          • Problem with commendations is there isn’t enough time to give them. The screen doesn’t load and the score board is on a different screen. If you try to check scoreboard to see who did what the commendation screen has to reload again and you are already back in orbit. Also, why does Hawthorne require you to give commendations to get powerful gear? I can do 20 events and only hand out 5 commendations because the screen won’t load or the players already left the activity. Also, I can’t view my own commendations screen or it crashes my game. I can look at other people’s screens but not my own. This needs a complete rework.

            Lingua:

             

            Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            1 Rispondi
            • You wanna know the actual point of guardian ranks Be Nice to each other... it is that simple Be better I literally don't care if you have 10 commendations or 10000 I literally don't care what rank you are The joy is in gaming together when it comes to these things.... If the screen loads fast enough, youl always get commendations of me Team work always is the 1st reason I look out for

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • Commendations: I’m happy to just hit the buttons to award commendations to my teammates before they, or the screen, disappears. I care not which commendation I pick, as long as I click one for each teammate. I’ve also encountered many players that simply don’t bother to award commendations… 🤔 Hey ho! 🫡

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • Didn’t know any of that! Meaningless for the game but interesting, thanks.

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • Triumph score tells me what I need to know about other players

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • Modificato da Týr-Skadi: 3/21/2023 9:46:01 PM
              Thanks

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • I like how you themed the commendation options around the characters really well!

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • Bungie's commendation and guardian ranks is a bad rip-off of CoDs Prestige system. And I do mean BAD. This is your brain :), this is your brain on fomo :(.

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

            • As far as I know, only 1 rank gives you anything for interacting with this pointless system. Rank 6 to 7 gives 4 more in-game loadouts to utilize. After that, I'm not aware of any benefits. (Someone please correct me if I'm wrong) Bungie said it was supposed to represent mastery within the game yet almost everyone started at Veteran. 3000hrs played? Veteran. Bought the game 3 weeks ago and masterworked a gun? Veteran. I personally have 0 desire to interact with this system until it's given a proper purpose, some benefits, and a change in the ladder to more accurately categorize players that actually represent their mastery, both past and present. In its current form, it's a waste of both player time and developer time.

              Lingua:

               

              Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

              2 Risposte
              • Modificato da neuroKip: 3/21/2023 12:12:51 PM
                I kinda like the streamlined concept you are proposing, that would be a more effective way to map player behavior to their commendation score. That said I still think commendation should be a reflection of your social behavior, rather than a reflection of your activity partecipation, you can get the most revives but display unpleasant behavior still. I wrote some thoughts about the commendation system too BTW. https://www.bungie.net/en/Forums/Post/262547148?sort=0&page=0

                Lingua:

                 

                Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

              • Some great ideas, it will always be ...want an example... I was in a raid group last week, all had day 1 emblems... Worst raid group I'd ever been in Non knew what to do.. This doesn't surprise me...its Destiny Every group I join for an activity I take on face value...not some number or rank

                Lingua:

                 

                Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

              • I disagree.

                Lingua:

                 

                Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

              • From rank 6 to 7 we got 4 additional loadout slots (6-->10). Ranks will be reset to default 6 = veteran next season? Will loadout slots be reset to 6 next season as well?

                Lingua:

                 

                Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                2 Risposte
                • For what its worth... I always give out commendations. It seems the right thing to do. (Unless someone is really a jerk...) We're all in this together right? So, at the end of each event I always pull up the Commendation screen. If your character is to the left of me, you get the card on the left. If you are to the right, you get the card on the right. Yes, fairly pointless in the scheme of things... But we all NEED these (for rank). However, if they were actually meaningless "by design" then they might actually be of more value... Ironic, isn't it?

                  Lingua:

                   

                  Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                  2 Risposte
                  • Pfft….rather get help ina lost sector. Don’t care about this terrible ranking system. Other news the auras is epic. Needs to come to endgame or ornaments.

                    Lingua:

                     

                    Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                  • The point of commendations and guardian ranks, is so players can see what to expect from each other on lfg boards (or atleast this is what bungie mention pre lightfall) Unfortunately, without negative commendations and the fact that they force players to use them. It makes it a pointless system. Imagine if we had commendations like poor sport (boots players or quits early), afk, griefer (pushes players off edge, starts encounters early), and angry (yells and blames other). While I'm sure some players would abuse these, for the most part it would give you a heads up, before joining and lfg. Just last week I had someone try to boost me right as the rewards dropped from a legendary campaign mission. Luckily, they were a second too slow.

                    Lingua:

                     

                    Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                    7 Risposte
                    • Guardian ranks and commendations mean nothing. A new light can reach "veteran" in under 6hrs, thats bot a veteran, thats the exact opposite of a veteran. Removes all meaning from the word and the system itself. Commendation were supposed to be a way to tell decent players from toxic ones, but bungie is to woke to let toxic players be called out so its just a joke system that means nothing. Both systems are nothing more than arbitrary numbers for you to chase to increase playtime to make shareholders happy. Neither have any value nor meaning.

                      Lingua:

                       

                      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                    • Commendations honestly mean nothing. I don't even realize I'm with other people in half the activities. At the end I just give them out based on who has the best fashion lol

                      Lingua:

                       

                      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                    • Commendations should not be required to get to level up. We should not rely on the good faith of others to level up our rank. If anything make that we have to GIVE commendations not receive. They are also pointless in that you get a determined set of commendations that mostly make no sense. It’s a cool system idea but locking progression behind it sucks. Also the screen crashes the game

                      Lingua:

                       

                      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                    • [quote]Issues this feedback addresses - Commendations feel hollow - Commendations feel like too much of a grind - Commendations don't accurately capture who I am as a guardian - Commendations are convoluted and I have no idea what I am handing out --- FEEDBACK Commendations are now AUTOMATIC and are untethered from guardian ranks. Guardian Ranks should only require feats (including PVP, yes I said it). Commendations fall into one of three color coded categories - Blue/Legend of Zavala (objective based accolades: most zones captured) - Red/Legend of Ikorra (damage based: most kills, most damage) - Green/Legend of Cayde (life of the party stats: most assists, revives) Lastly, auto commendations will also unlock one skin/shader after a player has reached the required threshold. Players also get access to one manual commendation at the end of an activity per player. Manual commendations fall into the same three color codes: - Blue/Legend of Zavala - Given to guardians who exemplified leadership - Red/Legend of Ikorra - Given to guardians who exemplified exceptional battle skill - Green/Legend of Cayde - Given to guardians who exemplified high fashion (lol) or humor Manual commendations do not give points, but instead can dictate what color a guardians rank (6) is above their heads. Players will be able to choose whether they want their automatic commendation color to show or their manual commendation color to show. Anyways - just some thoughts! Be safe out there Guardians![/quote] Bump

                      Lingua:

                       

                      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                    • You've come up with a better system than Bungie did.

                      Lingua:

                       

                      Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                      3 Risposte
                      • I think Commendation is helping for players play better with good manners especially when we play with random strangers. So I like it. Bungie reduced amount of requirement for the rank but it was unnecessary because by the time when players hit the light level high enough for solo legendary lost sector, everyone should hit 750 easily even solo players. But I hope make change for commendation - when we get from random strangers we should get more points than get it from fireteam and friends.

                        Lingua:

                         

                        Fate i bravi. Prima di postare date un'occhiata al nostro codice di condotta. Annulla Modifica Crea squadra Invia

                      Non ti è permesso visualizzare questo contenuto.
                      ;
                      preload icon
                      preload icon
                      preload icon