{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
8/9/2026 1:46:25 AM
9
Who could you defend in court, and what would your defense be?
Hot take: Nezerec the only innocent one here
-
Dredgen Yor. Wild West rules, and he really did only hunt Guardians, which can easily be painted in a negative light of “These guys were evil monsters, he was doing the world a favor”. This is made especially true as Shin Malphur, his killer, later creates the Shadows of Yor and becomes Dredgen Vale in order to draw out similarly corrupt and easily swayed Guardians to kill them. He did so with the assistance of Dredgen Cull. So the fact is, the Dredgens with the modern exception, and those who avoided the Shadows of Yor, had been acting for the benefit of Humanity. The fact is, Dredgen Yors legacy until recently had been one of virtue.
-
Clovis Bray because he's rich so he can just pay off everybody.
-
16 commentairesIsn't Clovis bray the genius who made the AIs that defended Earth for so long? Seems like a no brainer.
-
1 commentaireAll of the above have murdered between hundreds to millions of people.
-
1 commentaireThe Nezerec
-
Crota. He from birth was expected to destroy and fight for his existence, he was infected with a worm that feeds of destruction and his it's not fed it kills him, He can't show mercy or kindness or he is killed. I ask this court how is he expected to be good or kind if it leads to his death. His farther is a hive God who has the power to hunt him across the universe. He had no choice but to do evil he had no choice in trying to invade earth his will was dictated by a war like culture and a farther who would kill him if he tried to even show kindness he is a victim of hive doctrine.
-
1 commentaireModifié par jhermannITJ : 8/9/2026 3:48:06 AMMaya Sundaresh The only permutations in the simulations that allowed for our survival were ones where she lost herself... sacrificed herself. You can hear about it in Chioma's logs. She was tortured by it. She watched Maya die, over and over as the conductor. Maya made her witness it, over and over... so that when the time came she would holdfast. Maya changed Cayde... Cayde followed her because she is good. Endured the exo prototype experiments because he believed in her Echo protocols. And the research in question vital for our and all life's survival was her SiVA research. Quicksilver Nanites. And that only gets completed in timelines where she becomes corrupted, where a Dark Future emerges... and we're in it... the Winnower came online. I don't know if people really understand the significance of the secret cutscene in the Dark Forest amidst the shards of the Traveler. That confirms this IS a Dark Future timeline. Because, the Winnower only shows up there... the Gardener only manifests after the Winnower awakens. In a Dark Future. So, that's confirmed. And Cayde healed our Ghost with Quicksilver Nanites. The Traveler wasn't involved because of the Fungus... The Rot. That's what the Gardener does. Infects. Go inside the Traveler, the fungus is everywhere. Maya sacrificed herself to give us a chance. And she did... because our grave is empty, and this timeline is a Dark Future instance. In Neomuna... there's a mural that is based on a real piece of art of the Madonna. Right before you go fight Calus, you fight alongside Caital... after, the wall explodes behind you and you are directed one way, but there's a room ... and in that room a mural of Maya based on the Madonna. That's Maya. Mother of the Exos. Mother of the Cloudstriders. Mother of all life.
-
10 commentairesCrota. Correct me if I’m wrong, but he has never done anything “bad” he’s just a victim of vanguard propaganda. Has he even ever killed anyone? Yeah I didn’t think so. The defense rests.
-
Nezerac did nothing; it’s Bungie’s fault he's so easily solo cheesed.
