I think it's a good idea also, but not for the reasons you stated. Developers who release complete shit are doomed. That means utter crap like Aliens Colonial Marines is a death sentence. So guess what this door swings both ways and the consumer is going to stomp the crap out Microsoft and any developer and publisher who releases anything sub par. They are going to get stomped across the Internet . Pre Orders are going goodbye. Buying a game on impulse is over. Any game under 8 or lower in reviews is a dust collector on a Target fixture. So go ahead make it harder for consumers. They in the end are going to make it even harder on your bottom line. So yeah it's a good thing because it's going to make games better while crap developers and publishers die off.