I count Bloodborne as a Souls game. Big deal. But what's favorite. If we were going by ratings then Dark Souls 2 & 3 would be the worst. Dark Souls, the original was my favorite. My second favorite was Bloodborne followed by Dark Souls 2. And I didn't hate Demon Souls or Dark Souls 3. But they just didn't really compare to Dark Souls or Bloodborne.(opinion) But this is a poll for your own personal-taste.