Sounds like these turds don't know art criticism. Real artists feed off of criticism. They want to improve and criticism like this helps. I agree. It doesn't look like Destiny at all, looks far too ceremonial and impractical (far too steretypically mmo to be frank), it's interesting art though.

I agree it doesn't seem like it was made to fit Destiny's concept. All these concepts would feel out of place and foreign if put into the game. I also agree it needs more function and an more directed design towards the Titan class. Read the bio for the class look at what there purpose was and there skills and design around that.

You know, fair criticism. They have a lot of cumbersome spikes and what not, but these really seem to have an endgame armor set feel to them, which is where you expect the gaudy look at me armors to be.

Wether they "fit" destinys style or not theyre still badass and well made. I agree that endgame stuff is always over the top, I'd grind for all 3 sets :-b Good job buddy

I understand where you're coming from and I even agree a little after thinking about it, but there's no need to be abrasive. A simple "this is good art, but not really in the 'Destiny' flavor, here's why" would have sufficed, and saved you from getting crucified

Your criticism is an opinion- cannot be "right" or "accurate" and the idea that he can only improve by acting on your opinion is, to quote you, "comical"

Here is come constructive criticism regarding your criticism, Mr. Alchemist. You could have conveyed everything that you said like this: "Your technique is quite good. You are really good at creating a sense of material in each of the armor sets, and they have cohesive designs. If I had any criticism, it would be that these feel like they would be more at home in a more traditional, fantasy-based game, like World of Warcraft, rather than a sci-fi game like Destiny. I think that if you started by keeping in mind that every piece of armor is made to be very functional in Destiny, and built the form around that function, you'd probably achieve an even better result. Remember, that games like games like WoW have a more whimsical art direction, while games like Destiny seem to be attempting a greater degree of realism. Unfortunately, this may be a bit more restrictive on your designs." There is more to constructive criticism than merely giving the person your thought process. You have to be sufficiently polite, such that your advice isn't ignored when the person is offended at your tone. "They kind of suck," was not necessary , and added nothing to your otherwise very good advice. In any case, I don't think they DO suck. Perhaps, as you pointed out, not quite thematically appropriate for Destiny, but they are pretty cool nonetheless.

We are in agreement then, HUZZAH!

"They kinda suck" That is why I am disappointed in you. They don't suck. They look unreal. Really good concept. Yes I do agree that this set that he has made is less accurate to the Destiny feel, but in his other thread, he made some VERY accurate armor sets for the game.

Ok , take a look at the character armor sets in game, some are more cosmetic than these dude

You claim the practicality of the designs suck yet if you looked at the exotics gear that's in the game now. Barely any of it is as functional as you would like to imply. Infact one of the hunters chest plates is a freaken Christmas tree.

you know, if you go back and reread my comment, you would realise, i say the DESIGNS suck, and which, in my opinion they do, i even explained why they sucked, that said, i didn't say his artwork sucked. the "it's just a game so let him be creative" isn't a valid defense for designs which do not fit within the game world the concept art is for. if i got creative with a suit of armour designed for a player with a humanoid avatar, and i decided to make it look kickass with 6 arms, and 4 legs...it wouldn't fit in the player, it simply wouldn't work, and yes the design would suck at that point.