I'd say that this is a pretty well balanced fight.
They are both genetically enhanced soldiers, although Chief's suit might give him an advantage in speed and power.
Chief's suit protects him from a certain amount of damage from any point of contact, while Cap's shield is indestructible.
They're obviously both incredible tacticians and soldiers.
Who wins?
-
10 RepliesSo let's look at the stats: Short Range: Both are skilled hand to hand combatants, with cap having a slight advantage in hand to hand: point Cap Physical Capabilities: Both have been genetically altered, Cap more than Chief, but Master Chief has had extensive training since birth: Even Long Range: Cap shield may be indestructible, but if throwing a shield was better than guns, everyone would do it: Point Chief Defense: Cap: Indestructible Shield, and Light Body Armor. MC: Energy shields and Heavy Armor that allows one to survive a fall from space. I don't know exactly how Cap's shield will react to that armor, but it won't do much. It will hardly damage his shields. Absorbing vibrations won't help against magnetic shielding. Point: Chief Strategy/Tactics: Both have had extensive military training, both have fought through wars. No point awarded. Final: Cap 1 MC 2 What it turns out to be is two super-soldiers facing off. But Master Chief is from the future, so he wins