I don't really have a solid opinion yet. It's only been a couple of days and the Annual Pass is a drip feed of content spread out over 9 months. Analogically, I don't know what to think of an entire movie after I've only seen the first 5 minutes, and I don't know what to think of a book, as a whole, after reading the first chapter. I don't know what to think of the AP yet, and I don't know how anyone else knows what to think about the AP as a whole either. I haven't tried the forge because I need to level a little bit first, and apparently I am not utterly outraged by this. What's wrong with me? [b]EDIT: I have tried the forge a few times, failed (but came close a couple times), and I understand I will have to grind for LL a little more before I go back. It's decent. As for the Light grind, no big deal. [/b] [b]Initial Thoughts and Recommendations[/b]: Get it, if you plan on playing Destiny for the next year, and if you're fine with continuing to do your daily and weekly challenges for powerful gear to see what you get as you level up, which is the whole concept of the game. Get it if you are in the upper 500s in terms of light/power level (i.e., maybe 580+). Also, it's all you're going to get, in terms of new content beyond Forsaken, so you don't have much of a choice. Don't get it, if you don't like playing the game, or if you don't like regularly doing the milestones to increase your power/light, along with whatever other activities come along with the Pass. Don't get it if you want to immediately be able to access everything at once. That's not how this works. You'll need to be a certain light/power level to do things, like how most previous DLCs have operated. Don't get it if you're nowhere near 600. If you're not anywhere near 600 though, you probably haven't done everything in Forsaken, or don't have the time to have done everything, so you probably don't need the Annual Pass since you still have plenty to do, or can't play as much as you would like. If you're still busy with Forsaken, or aren't max light or close in Forsaken, you probably don't need this yet.
No one knows what to think of it because 90% can't even get the forge lit.