I think Bungie made the biggest possible blunder of all time for hyping a game and releasing it the way they did. It's my honest belief that if they didn't hype this game and published it as a quirky experience that you've just got to try, then they wouldn't have had the flack they got for years on end.
If it had released in its current state, with all the patches implemented, it would have been a widely different experience.
But to answer the question, yes, it is a good game. I am really looking forward to D2 now, as it seems that they have figured a lot of stuff out and it's all thanks to user feedback. Not everyone is going to get everything they want, but it will be a great game.
English