So far, VoG has been the best for me. What do you think?
Edit 1: CrotaGetsNoLove :(
Edit 2: If this ever dies, I'll bump it around the time the hard Kings Fall comes out. Then you can make your actual final verdict.
Edit 3: #SelfAdvertizing (Trials Clutches)
Edit 4: At the end of day one of this poll being alive, it looks like Xylar has taken the lead!
[spoiler]For now, maybe when the hard raid comes out...[/spoiler]
-
Crota is the best for flawless run for the trophy.
-
reason people think Vog was better was because it was something new. we were like "WoW" but when KF launched people knew what to expect.
-
10 RepliesVog is the best (still too many oracles, bungie needs to chill on the number 7) But i love the vog machanics. Forcing you to meed multiple people without being so overly complicated it takes years to explain. Its supposed to be a dungeon, not an instruction booklet on a rocket ship
-
Kings Fall is amazing thus far but I remember being forever 29 running VOG I personally felt more of an attachment to the Vault Raid so I am more inclined to vote for VOG. Kings Fall on the other hand has more mechanics but they don't make me feel like I'm walking on thin ice like in the Vault of Glass.
-
Kings fall is better than vault
-
VOG is better. In KF their are 4 bosses but your really fighting 2. Golgroth and warpriest are shooting/attacking you. All oryx does is slam his fists and the daughters just float in the air saying hey just shoot me in the head. Also VOG weapons>KF weapons
-
Edited by Skyrender6: 10/17/2015 12:44:40 PMVOG is incredible no doubt--and the Templar fight is one of the most intense boss fights in any video game, ever, I think. I think that VOG is better than Kingsfall because it pushed your skills closer to the limit. Granted that KF is much more heavy on mechanics... But, once you join a team that fully understands the mechanics it becomes a stroll through the park. A lot more shit could go wrong in VOG on the other hand. Just because you knew the mechanics well didn't mean that any great number of things could go wrong. I personally enjoy puzzles and for that reason like KF better, but I do think as a whole that VOG is the better raid. TL;DR VOG = high skill/medium mechanics, KF = low to medium skill/high mechanics, both are great, VOG is a little better Edit: one thing I think both are missing are some good old fashioned run and gun segments. KF has that segment before the ships where you have to get past acolytes--I wish there was a little more of that just to stir the rhythm up a bit.
-
Edited by lickwid elite: 10/17/2015 7:23:44 AMVOG > KINGS FALL >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> CROTA>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> POE [spoiler]IMHO[/spoiler]
-
Mechanic wise, Kings Fall blows the other two out of the water
-
think we can all agree that OP is a -blam!-
-
Been here for all the raids and I still think King's Fall is the best. It's the largest, the most challenging, and has more of a sense of "don't -blam!- up" than the other 2.
-
Edited by Sych0n0ught: 10/17/2015 12:16:33 PMVault > Kings Fall > Crota The vault was so hard originally, took me forever. Kings Fall we blew through the first time in a couple hours. But the team work for both is what I like about those. In Crota you could more or less run through it. But Crota got me Icebreaker, Patience And Time, and Black Hammer in the same day so I think it was nicer with drops.
-
1 ReplyNot a fan of VoG. Kings Fall has better mechanics, and you're not forced to wait in every single encounter. Can't tell you how much I hated things like Oracles and opening the Vault. It's just some mechanic there to delay your success. That's one of the reason I'm not a huge fan of totems in King's Fall.
-
3 RepliesTry answering this after hard mode kings fall is released. Bungie made kings fall hard mode first before removing some mechanics and making normal mode.
-
2 RepliesThe best part about vog is it's in the patrol world and it's cool watching people enter
-
who wants to do VoG Msg wildmonkey661
-
VoG was great and so was the loot!
-
VoG was epic but I feel the jumping puzzles in KF are a lazy way to fill in a set of vast spaces
-
If they just make everything in KF hard have yellow bars, I'll be disappointed. Hopefully building it hard then normal will have changed that stupid design.
-
Bump. -blam!- TTK.
-
We can't really justify this yet. Kings fall normal, was created second. Hard mode came first so we got the dumbed down version. I believe that VoG and CE normal were made first, then hard mode second. So until we see hard mode, I won't vote. BUT. Hard mode KF better be hard.
-
Vog is probably the most fun single activity in any game I've ever played.
-
1 ReplyKing's Fall is great up until Oryx. He's a damn epic looking boss, but I dont actually feel like we're fighting him. We kinda run around killing adds and stuff and shooting his chest to stop us from dying. Not until his last stand does it feel like a fight. VoG however was epic. All six piled up on a tiny platform, blowing the hell out of Atheon as he helplessly fired into the Shield to no effect. Definitely my fave. And Crota was awesome, but it again felt more like standing by while our swordbearer did most the work (even though we dropped his shield). So: VoG > KF > CE > PoE
-
They need to add encounters with mini boss's before we come up against a main boss. we run from boss to boss with nothing to slow us down.
-
1 ReplyI love kings fall and vog pretty much equal They do two different things very well
-
3 RepliesVoG had better pacing, better atmosphere, tougher enemies, and the mythocast waiting to be claimed. Kings fall is excellent, much better than Crota ' s end. But in the end, it falls short in a few areas. The best 6 man raid is still the Vault.