I'm option 5. Only in the face of indisputable evidence would I ever convert.
Also, have you ever converted someone either to religion or from it? I've converted 3 people to atheism. Here's a fun question: Has The Flood ever had an influence on your religious beliefs or lack thereof? My guess is that it hasn't had any effect on over 90% of frequent users. This should be interesting.
-
I am religious but open to the possibility of becoming a misotheist or one who does not like God. I can confidently say that I would never change my religion for another--the way I feel is that after discovering my religion, there is no coming. It's either Orthodoxy to the end or bust. No other religion fills the void for me. I need the Incarnation. That said though, the possibility of burning out or turning against God is very real in my life. Not atheism--it's too influenced by the precise thing it disbelieves in--but more so misotheism or distrust for God.