Hi so recently I've had the cattle error on my Xbox one and I found a fix that I couldn't find on YouTube or any forum! I tried every single one of the methods to fix the error (multiple times each) and I've had no luck. If you use Comcast, go to your Internet browser and search up the website for your router. You should be able to Google "xfinity router login" and from there simply just set your firewall to "Low" if you had it on "medium/high" setting. This might not help the average destiny player but if it can help at least one person I'll be happy :) Goodluck with your cattle error!