I'm annoyed by the large amount of people ridiculing IGN for the Pokémon ORAS review on their site, mainly because of the "Too much water" criticism that was given. It annoys me because so few people seem to realize what the reviewer was trying to get to.
Here's a quote from the article: "Hoenn is still imbalanced type-wise, heavily favoring water. It’s especially noticeable in Alpha Sapphire, in which Team Aqua (the villains of the piece) use a lot of water types. It feels like there are water Pokémon in nearly every battle, and I have an overleveled Pikachu to show for it. You also have to navigate many bodies of water, since much of the late-game involves the HMs Surf and Dive to get from place to place. Diving was really neat back in 2002 when it was new, but I found it incredibly tedious in Alpha and Omega — an obvious example of how superfluous some HMs are."
Not only was the reviewer critiquing the poor type balance, but also tying into an earlier critique about the overuse of HMs, which would be required for many areas and items. The reviewer was trying to say that there could've been massive improvements for these issues along with other parts of the game, but instead most people just skipped to the end and saw "Too much water".
Was "Too much water" poorly written? Yes. Does it have a legitimate reason to be there? Yes. Does the reviewer deserve such heavy criticism from the gaming community? Not really. This whole mess is a result of a lack of research into the actual review from the community, and poor communication in the final summary from the reviewer.
I'm not saying IGN is right on everything. I thought the game Thomas Was Alone was a masterpiece, but IGN didn't think of it that highly. I really like CoD Black Ops for its well-written story and great multiplayer, but IGN thought it was tame compared to BO2, a game that I still like, but not as much as the original. Many people hated their positive review of CoD Ghosts, and I can understand. But you have to remember, not only is IGN made up of multiple journalists, but they all have their separate opinions. Not everybody will agree with you on everything, and you need to realize that.
IGN saying something you don't like or agree with should not automatically be bribery or incompetence, yet that's how many gamers view them, and it depresses me to see so much hate towards them. If you people are going to hate on IGN, at least give a valid reason, not just "I don't like their opinion" or "Too much water hurrdurr".
If any of you guys have real, valid criticisms towards IGN with real ground to stand on, and not just conspiracies or anger towards their opinions, I'd be perfectly willing to listen.
English
#Gaming
-
Edited by Spookofdaskelton: 8/29/2015 10:02:42 PMDecent post but just too much water. IGN rate 7.8/10
-
Dihydrogen monoxide is an acid with a pH of 7. Thats the highest pH of any acid! And we put it in our food!?
-
Gears of War: Ultimate Edition 8.5 - Using A button too much. IGN is full of keks
-
Legend of Zelda windwaker "Too much water"
-
You can't kill the memes.
-
Edited by STDs101: 9/1/2015 5:48:01 PMToo much dick up the ass from IGN- 7.64/10
-
"Needs more cowbell" - IGN
-
Hoen is my personal favorite region (mostly because the Treeko family is absolutely amazing). The water doesn't bother me.
-
Edited by Jr23TypeR: 9/1/2015 7:53:45 AMWhy do people go to IGN for reviews anyways. They are not very smart when it comes to games. They really are a joke. I mean they gave Until Dawn a 7.5 just because THEY didn't understand why a character was in the game. Which clearly if you beat the full game the right way and find all the clues you will understand the game completely. They rush through games just to write up a lousy review. I mean shouldn't the "too much water" give you a sign about them? You want good honest reviews they're plenty of other better sources. ***STAY AWAY FROM IGN REVIEWS***
-
I agree
-
Too much water....... Too much use of a button...... Ign doesnt have a clue about anything
-
Yes it should be changed to too much A button. It's not a conspiracy if you actually look into. I cannot believe any real gamer would try and defend IGN.
-
I agree. In recent studies it has been proven that 100% of all people who drink water will die. This silent ( & wet) killer needs to be stopped.
-
I'm guessing you have no idea what a meat sheath feels like.
-
Is this about Pokemon? Isn't that a kids game
-
Edited by Sora Orth: 9/1/2015 4:53:42 AMI've [i]just[/i] been replaying then old emerald, and on the all water types, there's much more dark types then water IMO, also surf/dive where the promanaet features of R/S, it's not like they can change the region, as what's the point of remaking the games then? Also most of the water types (excluding kyoge and Aqua bosses) they are stupidly weak to lots of things, so the need to carry a electric Pokemon at all times is also dumb. Yes the amount of surfing you do gets slightly annoying, but fly exists for a reason, and they can't change/remove the dive parts because it was a good chunk of the game, also the [i]only[/i] to use dive outside of battle. Also we don't fully bash it for it being a dumb opinion, we bash it for how much they lowered the score via it. Then again what am I saying, this is also the group who gives cod 8-9s every year.
-
Edited by Lord Ocram: 8/30/2015 2:18:40 AMScrew IGN! I get my info from posters, Friends and youtube![spoiler]also, LONG LIVE MY SHINY RAYQUAZA. MAY YOUR DRACO METEOR CRUSH ALL MY FOES! [/spoiler]
-
Remember the time they made a video bashing fans who were concerned about the quality of Battlefront? [spoiler]You could smell the paycheck[/spoiler]
-
they rated the worst Hyperdimension Neptunia game a 6, which is reasonable. but then they rated the Hyperdimension Neptunia with a fuk ton of improvements (better story, better combat, better graphics, more enemy types) a 5.6 wtf.
-
You must work for IGN Your post deserves a.......7.8/10 Sorry but it has too much water
-
Everyone hates IGN as they rate every game very poorly. This joke is for all of IGNs reviews, like a summary of their awful review team.
-
26 here and I have to wear a long jacket [b]just so I can play Pokemon!!![/b] what has this world come to? Gengar, you're my boy.
-
My main issue with the ORAS review was that it was rated lower then the original game.
-
yes this DOES need to die.. but it'll have to die from Drowning because there's TOO MUCH WATER!!!
-
-1/10 - too much water
-
It's been dead wtf are you taking about?