Votes Toland but I'd like to throw pujari into the mix. For one, he found the black garden originally. While in that death state of wondering he did in the garden he encountered a ghost shape flower. When he went to pluck it, it cut him with a Thorn and he bled, and the blood was [i]light[/i]. It then went on to comment how he and the traveler were just murders. "You are a dead thing, created by a dead power, in the shape of the dead. All you will do is kill. This is a place of life" when pujari heard this he may began to doubt himself and the traveler. When he was ressurect ed he retained his cut, it never healed. In this, I belive it was pujari who was the one to become Dredgen Yor. As the Noble man that yor had been also had doubted the light and traveler. I find it ironic that pujari was wounded with a Thorn and that he bled light. I believe the "bleeding" of light started to turn him towards darkness. After witnessing horrors and committing some himself is when we began to see his true change as he slowly became Yor. While we don't know what class of warlock pujari is it would make sense that yor was a warlock. When he faced off against Jaren ward I believe he lost the draw on Jaren and the last word, ironically using the last of his light to self ressurect and fire into Thorn. It would explain why Jarens ghost was shocked, exclaiming "he never misses" Also would explain how yor easily burnt down a town. Most likely a sunsinger and my guess, a shit ton of solar nades. Tl:Dr pujari is Dredgen yor

Let's see 🤔 My guardian has : 1. Killed the Heart of the Black garden 2.Killed Atheon 3. Killed Crota 4. Killed Skolas 5. Killed Oryx 6. Killed Askis 6. Beat super Mario brothers with 1 man and no warps. I'm not trying to toot my own horn here but come on!!!! I should at least be considered for employee of the month and have my picture posted in the tower's bathroom or behind Eris to cheer people up.

Flawed list: You forgot to add Gul'dan, Archimonde the Defiler, Kil'jaeden the Deceiver, Cho'gall, Grandmaster Vorpil, Blackheart the Inciter, Zelfrax, Zinnin the Worgen, and Neeru Fireblade

You stole my idea.

I really wanna know what toland and Osiris actually look like. I feel toland would look very hive like just like eris

I'm upset that praedyth was forgotten. Suppose that's what happens when you become an anomaly in a dimension controlled by time traveling radiolaria cyborgs Either way, toland wins

Felwinter used shoulder charge, so he gets my vote. That's the closest thing we'll ever get to a titan with blink ;)

Its a close one between Osiris, Toland, and Praedyth (i think that is how you spell it) Lore wise, Toland has infiltrated the Hive Overworld. He is mapping them out and finding weaknesses that the Hive and by extent the Worms that reside in the Deep have. Eris's rock is the physical link Toland's soul has in our realm, and must be protected. Osiris is hiding out on Mercury, doing the same thing that Toland is but with the Vex and a bit differently. Osiris is still alive, and can time travel. He was instrumental in the battle of six fronts before he left the city. (Saint 14 describes Osiris as being in six places at once, Osiris could time travel back then.) Osiris has a connection to the light that most likely surpasses the Speaker, who used to be a legendary guardian forgotten to time. (Yes, the Speaker is actually very, very powerful) Praedyth has the least amount going for him, and normally wouldn't be considered except for one thing: The vex have locked him outside of time (he was presumed to have been expunged, but this isnt the case), yet he is fighting them. Despite being under lock and key, Praedyth made a device to enable him to communicate with our realm (why we talk to him during the Paradox mission, plus Taken upsetting the Vex control on their Throne World replica that is called the Vault of Glass) Praedyth may not have conventional power, but he is resisting the Vex despite lacking power. In my opinion, Toland (current Toland, as he maps the Hive Overworld) is equally strong as Osiris. However Toland has the Darkness and the Light empowering him (some what under his control).Osiris has a nearly unrivaled connection to the Light, and can time travel. Praedyth is not as strong as those two, but shows that his weakness will not hinder him (he is the only Guardian to survive an expungence, he is not using a power to stay alive. Toland could employ a mixture of Light and some Hive magic, Osiris could time travel or something similar. Praedyth has done neither.) Even if the Vex were allowing Praedyth to remain alive, Praedyth is still resisting them. He is not strong in conventional terms, but something that is very hard to describe. Regardless, Praedyth is weaker than Toland and Osiris. But, should all three of them be placed under restraints (unable to use the majority of their powers, and unable to revert the restraints) Praedyth would be the strongest because Praedyth is the most resilient despite his weakness in comparison to Toland and Osiris. TL/DR: Toland and Osiris's different powers even out in general. Praedyth is the most resilient, and shows hints that his weakness limits his survivability far less than the other two. (Praedyth's weakness is the weakest) Edit: Fixed Praedyth's name. It has received a 1.002 % buff.

Dredgen Yor bruh

Felwinter was a titan

Wherea purji.

If I were to vote on the statement "knowledge is power" I'd have to say Osiris. Because who could ever hope to defeat someone who has peered into the rivers of time?

Ikora. I hear back in [i]her crucible days[/i] she beat the hell out of Shaxx so hard he still has trouble sitting.

Sorry I meant Praedyth

In the Crucible, out of those names perhaps Felwinter will win. In terms of the lore and how powerful a Warlock can actually become, the answer is either Toland or Osiris. We can imagine how powerful either of them must be, but we lack any definitive details to make any one final answer

Osiris, unlike the others, except for Ikora, are still alive.