If you buy a tshirt in large and add a couple pounds, you don't get the XL for free. If you buy a tshirt in XL and drop a few pounds, you don't get the L for free. I know that doesn't really say what you want it to but when you actually look at the scenario at its base business plan, it's spot on. Bungie did EVERYONE a huge bonus with the upgrade program the first year. And many people took advantage of it. But it was a bonus. The way I see it. I've spent 65$ on destiny at launch, expansion pass for 35$ at launch and TTK for 40 on 360 and 40 on xbone with the collectors edition for 20. Grand total: 200$ for 2 full years of content and gameplay. 3 of my friends buy a new game every month cause there is always something new coming out and they usually finish them in 30 days. New game 65$ x 24 (two full years of gameplay) = 1560$ Now let's say they trade in their games to gamestop at the max 30$ bringing their new game total to 35$ 35$ x 24 = 840$ And just for a laugh let's say they only bought games every other month and still got the 30$ trade in 35 x 12 = 420$ So the way I see it, even if you spent 200$ on destiny, if you enjoy the game, do it. Your still spending less than others.