I visited this thread to see a debate about video games, I stayed for the flame war between Frost and Bookshelf. You two are hilarious. OT: I preferred Reach honestly. Invasion was such a wonderful gametype, and while I do enjoy Dominion, I never felt like there were any worthy new gametypes in Halo 4. Invasion did for Reach what Infection did for Halo 3 IMO, and even Halo 4 screwed that up. Reach had an amazing forge level, yes it had a grey palette and had static lighting, but now in Halo 4 we have white, undetailed blocks that produce a patchy dynamic lighting. Firefight was far more enjoyable for me than Spartan Ops, whose storyline is poorly tacked on to boring grinding fights. Firefight had survival undertones that made it alot more enjoyable. It's a fact that Reach had superior Theater mode too. That being said, I do enjoy Halo 4's levels and audio more. I feel like both games were the low point of the series in general though.