I'm predicting that in a couple years, when 343 has the time it needs to shoot out a game that bears the full potential of it's talent, it will win GOTY. It should get Halo back on track after Halo 4, which was nothing but a minor speed bump in an otherwise beautiful game franchise.
Also, GTA 5 and Splinter Cell should duke in out next year for GOTY.
-
I think it may or may not win. I predict those odds are better.