we have beaten the puddle that was the horse about this focus your attention on another weapon that is currently more dangerous than thorn, which is the hack moon
compare the thorn which works like this
[b]thorn[/b]
[u][b]2 hit kill range requires[/b][/u]
head and body shot
head and head shot
[u][b]3 hit kill range requires[/b][/u]
body, body, head
body, body, body
[b]hawk moon[/b]
[u][b]1 hit kill range[/b][/u]
luck in the chamber, holding aces
[u][b]2 hit kill range requires[/b][/u]
head, head
head, body
holding aces, body
luck in the chamber, body
[u][b]3 shot kill range requires [/b][/u]
body. body, head
body, body, body,
body, body, luck in the chamber
body, body, holding aces
body lucking the chamber, holding aces
need i say more?
edit: here is some more information
[u]Timur's Lash precision only[/u] = (12 x 604) + 805 = 8053 This is with one luck in the chamber.
single precision shot PVP = 95 or 127 or more depending on roll
[u]Hawkmoon precision only[/u] = (10 x 573) = 5730 + 764 +764 +764 = 8022 This is with three lucky bullets in the chamber.
single precision shot PVP = 94 or 126 with a perk round
[u]Thorn precision only [/u]= (9 x 512) = 4608 + (7 * 6)*9 mark of devourer perk = 378 =4986
single precision shot PVP = 81 + perk = 123
[b]edit 4/9/15: option for changes that could balance the weapons[/b]
if they reduce the impact to thorn people will still complain about the burn damage, if thats nerfed along with impact then people will say its firing too fast and after all the nerfs it will be hitting less than acceptable in PVE against enemies, and in PVP it would destroy the guns competitive potential almost certainly makings it similar to the devil you dont but slower
whats funny is that the last word and thorn are preaty similar
both have the same fire rate of 32
both have an impact of 68
the differences start popping up around the other stats Hawkmoon is on its own level
Thorn (long range clean up)
ROF = 32
IMP = 68
RNG = 38
STB = 31
RLD = 43
MAG = 9
needs to be: fire rate 32, impact 50 , range 40, stability 35-40, reload 45-50, magazine 9, and burn damage does less but stacks with every hit
Last Word (close quarters fast clean up)
ROF = 32
IMP = 68
RNG = 14
STB = 31
RLD = 56
MAG = 8
needs to be: fire rate 45, impact 75, range 20, stability 31, reload 65, magazine 6, and stability needs to be doubled to 61 while hip firing
Hawkmoon (medium/long range power house)
ROF = 22
IMP = 81
RNG = 38
STB = 41
RLD = 39
MAG = 13
too much impact to be as stable as it is
needs to be: fire rate 25, impact 65, range 38 stability 35-40 reload 40-45, magazine 10, take away the first luck in the chamber perk and replace with performance bonus which puts free ammo back into your reserves when you kill enemies, keep the holding aces the same but remove the bug that allows the perk to stack with itself.
-
Glad you put all the statistics up but in pvp I rather face a whole team of hawkmoon users than a whole team of thron users any day
-
People will get mad at what kills them. It doesn't matter what it is.
-
Hack moon? Really? You realise the 1 hit kill chance on a hawkmoon is 0.22% when fully loaded right? It's only a 37.14% chance of a two shot kill when fully loaded. Thorn is always a 2 headshot kill with a faster fire rate. I use thorn and love it. I also know it is overly powerful when compared to most other exotic primaries. RIP Suros. People like to win, therefore they use Thorn. Lots of People using Thorn makes lots of people cry on the forums. Blame bungie for making the majority of other exotics useless in comparison.
-
No gun bothers me like shotguns especially being killed by felwinter's lie Only exception is universal remote
-
Edited by Ronin Yojimbo: 4/8/2015 9:26:15 PMMore often than not, I WILL spend the extra round to the head to make sure yer dirtnappin'. I mean I got 116 rounds, 3 ain't much . . . & I can drop people just as well with Timur's Lash.
-
If people can rapidly land 2 headshots on you with thorn, you probably shouldn't be playing crucible. JUST MOVE AROUND
-
Thorn op pls nerf kthnx
-
Could people stop complaining about people getting mad at thorn users...GOSH BECKIE!
-
High aim assist, high range, high accuracy. It's like giving PR full auto and a reflex sight.
-
Thorn Fast fire rate High impact Burn damage 5 ticks dealing 7 damage a tick giving 35 damage per shot adding to whatever damage thorn does otherwise Shoot wait a second for 2 ticks shoot again and you die Red death got a silent nerf to it's healing Before it would fully heal you and stop the burn damage Now it heals until the next tick hits you leaving you often at 1 bar of health Thorn needs either, an impact nerf, a fire rate nerf, reduce burn damage to 3 or 4
-
So your argument for why Thorn isn't cheap is that another HC is cheaper? That's like saying a Corvette is slow because it will get beat by a Veyron. For those of us on Xbox, Thorn stands out even more. It's easy mode for less skilled players, and a complete crutch.
-
Edited by JaeMech: 3/2/2015 6:20:13 AMYou survived the thorn bounty but the barbs cast at you by those unskilled enough to claim this weapon bothers you? Wield the Thorn with pride and care not for the opinions of the weak.
-
Thorn is a pain but it requires some skill so I can't be mad LAWL
-
I don't think it's cheap, its just annoying as -blam!-
-
Thorn = crutch. Only noobs use it because they can't finish somebody off right, instead they shoot twice and run.
-
If I'm playing a video game, I'm going to get angry.
-
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5T-J39Y3VH4
-
-
U missed the fact that both perks can stack on one bullet and 1 shot from anywhere on anywhere.
-
Thorn is a crutch. It just FEELS easier to use. It angers me more than TLW, vex, red death, panic smash, anything, etc.
-
I stopped caring about the thorn complaints and started using it when crucible turned into nothing but shotguns and fusion rifles, now I run thorn and praedeths revenge with my deviant gravity for PvP .
-
Only way to 2 hit someone with Thorn is 2 headshots
-
But...But...Xbox...
-
Lol OP brings up the Hawkmoon OHK as evidence. You think getting a OHK (1/13^3) is common? [spoiler]I don't think thorn is OP tho[/spoiler]
-
Ive never 1hk some one with Hkmoon. 2shot yea but never 1 and most people that use thorn just hit twice and run expecting the DOT dmg to kill you. Cant tell you how many times I've out gunned people with thorn because they don't know how to aim. Now I'm not saying all thorn users a like this but the majority are.
-
I've been using Thorn since about November or October and I'm happy it got buffed. I love helping my team. I also use my TDYK, Crusader, and TLW, so it's not a crutch for me, just one of my favorite weapons.