Bottom line is PVE & PVP gear should not be the same.....Wow figured this out long ago when they started adding resilience to pvp gear. If someone that is a hardcore raider comes into a pvp match against someone with max pvp gear with resil or whatever they'd call it, advantage to pvp player hands down. This imo will be the only way to keep the community happy. There should be equivalent gear available to both pve and pvp with some minor stat changes geared for pve or pvp.