neither A low level player could have decent wins and k/d because all he plays against are average and below average players. He thinks he's a badass but thats because he plays will lower tiered opponents and the kills and wins come much easier. Meanwhile a super skilled player plays against very hard opponents who don't know what losing is. His stats won't be as good in k/d and wins. Put the high skill players who appears to have "lower stats" with the below average player with "good stats" and you see a lopsided, 1 sided, massacre coming from the skilled player. While stats can be an indication of a player' skill they never truly reveal all. Unless a skill rank is associated with a player just plain k/d and wins like in call of duty or battlefield don't show the level of skill a player goes against. Obviously there are exceptions to this rule. We can assume a player with a .5 k/d isn't that great since even a good player should be above a 1 k/d at least sicne they would beat most average players and only have to deal with real skilled opponents.