Also if 6 was the Rookie (HE IS NOT) the UNSC would have used him as a major propaganda tool. Another human who survived Reach. (I still believe that 6 survived after Lone Wolf, hey I can hope)

The Rookie was fighting on New Juroselum (excuse my spelling) at the time of the fall of Reach, according to anime/book cannon. Bungie has not stated that N6 is the Rookie, so that's impossible. Plus six is taller. But nice card. [Edited on 12.14.2010 5:48 PM PST]

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent As seen on [url=http://img139.imageshack.us/img139/5056/floodguts.png]Bungie's Christmas card[/url] the Rookie and N6 are the exact same size, so it is obvious that they are the same person, as already hinted at extensively in both ODST and Reach. [b]Note: To all people saying the stupid "Noble 6 died" crap, not only can an unarmored Marine survive a sword through the chest as shown in [i]Midnight on the Heart of Midlothian[/i] but the sword was never even shown touching Noble 6.[/b][/quote] Read "Dirt" in the Halo: Evolutions. The Rookie was confirmed to be on [url=http://halo.wikia.com/wiki/Dirt]another planet[/url] when Reach fell.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent As seen on [url=http://img139.imageshack.us/img139/5056/floodguts.png]Bungie's Christmas card[/url] the Rookie and N6 are the exact same size, so it is obvious that they are the same person, as already hinted at extensively in both ODST and Reach. [b]Note: To all people saying the stupid "Noble 6 died" crap, not only can an unarmored Marine survive a sword through the chest as shown in [i]Midnight on the Heart of Midlothian[/i] but the sword was never even shown touching Noble 6.[/b][/quote] The reason he didn't die in Midnight on the Heart of Midlothian is because he was hopped up on battle stims and had adrenalin flowing through his body like the Hudson River

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] a cod fish But 6 got put on a covie kabob[/quote] and reach was glassed so even if he wasnt killed or taken prisonor by the covies he'd be dead because he barely survived the fall from the corvet

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] ryanhalo798 Plus, why would a Spartan become an ODST? They've hated each other since about 2525[/quote] True, the Spartan IIs pissed off a battalion of ODSTs before they got augmented

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] MyMovesAreNinja if you took the time to read the thread this guy gives ample proof they are the same person.[/quote]Lol, Not even close. It makes no sense at all.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] MyMovesAreNinja if you took the time to read the thread this guy gives ample proof they are the same person.[/quote] And if you took the time to look at my post, you would think otherwise. [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Darktemplar4 The Rookie was fighting at the Battle of New Jerusalem on September 2552 and was one of the few survivors. He hailed a Pelican and was informed that Reach had been glassed and that survivors were retreating to Earth. Even if Noble 6 survived the firefight with the Elites, there is no way that he would live with an Energy Sword through his abdomen, survive the glassing of Reach, be sent to New Jerusalem and forever be known as the Rookie.[/quote] [Edited on 12.14.2010 5:47 PM PST]

Why do people keep thinking noble 6 is the rookie or master chief...? just give it up already

Plus, why would a Spartan become an ODST? They've hated each other since about 2525

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.[/quote] And question, Arent spartans more advanced due to augmentations? Wouldn't he be about to bend a simple sniper rifle? [/quote] A lot of that strength comes from Mjolnir, and the Spartan's enhanced bones are why they're the only ones (Legends notwithstanding) who can use it. Injured, and without Mjolnir, probably not.[/quote]With MJOLNIR yes, and without probably MJOLNIR and the Spartan's strength are different, III's get the cheapest version which most likely does not have the muscle cloth that the version the Spartan II's have

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] ryanhalo798 Don't try. This retard come come up with an arguement for anything[/quote] Some people are good at sports, I can make up a BS argument for any crap you have that isn't direct proof. I've already been proven wrong, but since people refuse to read I get to continue this thread. [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] GetawayGuy24 Yeah, 6 is taller. /thread[/quote] Take an art class, learn perspective. [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] JAS CHAOS Zero [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.[/quote] SPARTANS CANNOT voulentarily downgrade themselves. It just doesn't work that way. Some ODSTs trained some of the Spartan IIIs[/quote] ANYONE CAN be demoted from an injury received during battle.

Haha I cant believe you're trying to pass this off as if you were not being serious.

if you took the time to read the thread this guy gives ample proof they are the same person.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] blagsc [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] ryanhalo798 WELL IF HE/SHE DID LIVE, THEY WOULD ACTUALLY PICK UP THEIR HELMET. God[/quote] That's the funniest thing I've seen so far! But wait, it was broken, why would he want a broken helmet? @Guy talking about Elite honor system, as I said before, I think most elites would assume N6 was dead after getting stabbed by the energy sword. But as we know it is possible to survive that, especially with the instant biofoam canisters in Mjolnir armor.[/quote] Hmm true true.....S3s had a limited biofoam though they could heal them selfs but limited so it could stop the pain and the bleeding.....so yeah he could of lived (S2s had the biofoam that could heal them fully but yeah) but then we have the problem of how did he get off reach even though there is a shipyard nearby the covies are glassing reach so..... Also how did we get that big hole in our helmets when on our screen there is 2? [/quote] I'm sure there was scattered military outposts across Reach that hadn't been hit by the time PoA left. And of course from the data pads and First Strike we know the Covenant can't actually glass a whole planet, so it is possible. [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] ivantheigor [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] carby21 [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent As seen on [url=http://img139.imageshack.us/img139/5056/floodguts.png]Bungie's Christmas card[/url] the Rookie and N6 are the exact same size, so it is obvious that they are the same person, as already hinted at extensively in both ODST and Reach. [b]Note: To all people saying the stupid "Noble 6 died" crap, not only can an unarmored Marine survive a sword through the chest as shown in [i]Midnight on the Heart of Midlothian[/i] but the sword was never even shown touching Noble 6.[/b][/quote] This instantly gets shot out of the water. If you look at N6 in the picture its the female model. This is the most pathetic thing ever. Please get some facts on halo before you come here because people who are veterans of halo like me will laugh at these ridiculous ideas. Go [url=http://www.halopedian.com/Main_Page]here[/url] for some halo facts. [/quote] Halopedian is maintained by 4-5 egocentric asshats whom all believe they are superior and their opinion matters more than anyone else's because they have special privileges. And calling yourself a "Halo veteran" when you were a Major Grade 3 in H3 is pretty funny.[/quote] And this is why we dont have visible ranks anymore. Douche bag[/quote] Meant it more as a joke, along with most of this thread, but people take things way too seriously all the time.[/quote] Sorry Ive seen these posts so many times its a knee jerk reaction Im not taking this thread seriously.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.[/quote] And question, Arent spartans more advanced due to augmentations? Wouldn't he be about to bend a simple sniper rifle? [/quote] A lot of that strength comes from Mjolnir, and the Spartan's enhanced bones are why they're the only ones (Legends notwithstanding) who can use it. Injured, and without Mjolnir, probably not.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.[/quote] SPARTANS CANNOT voulentarily downgrade themselves. It just doesn't work that way. Some ODSTs trained some of the Spartan IIIs [Edited on 12.14.2010 5:39 PM PST]

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] JAS CHAOS Zero [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Sandtrap Then how come the rookie, AND Noble 6 are standing next to each other?[/quote] That is just Bungie giving us more (on top of an already huge pile of) hints.[/quote] Then how the hell could they be standing next to each other if they are the SAME PERSON?[/quote] there standing next to eachother BECAUSE there the same person.

Yeah, 6 is taller. /thread

Don't try. This retard come come up with an arguement for anything

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] ryanhalo798 This thread is the funniest thing I've seen. I don't think he/she is the Rookie. Rookie: He enlisted on July 7th, 2547. Noble Six: SPARTAN-B312 was taken out of Beta Company immediately after training, according to a communiqué from Kurt Ambrose to Franklin Mendez that was sent in May 2545, two months before Operation: TORPEDO. [b] Problem Solved [/b] Noble Six was pulled out of Beta Company before The Rookie even enlisted you idiot [/quote] N6 was pulled from Beta, then two years later (remember how far away Onyx was from everything, the damn slipspace jumps could have taken that long) the Rookie enlists. Still plausible, just with some ONI faking/combining of military records.

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.[/quote] And question, Arent spartans more advanced due to augmentations? Wouldn't he be about to bend a simple sniper rifle? Spartan 3's were sent of suicide missions. And not expected to live. They could only reach to a certain rank, And I don't think they had a choice of relocation. [Edited on 12.14.2010 5:38 PM PST]

Well Rookie was [url=http://halo.wikia.com/wiki/The_Rookie]6'1"[/url] and the hieght of Noble 6 is unknown. But as we can see from the rest of the noble team it is unlikley that he was under 6'10" since the rest of noble team was around that hieght with Kat being the known shortest at 6'9". I'm fairly confident in saying that Kat was a lil shorter than Noble 6 as well. The reason for the unknown face of Rookie and Noble 6 is just for the players benefit. So we can picture our selves as both characters so with that logic they are the same person and that person is.....drum roll......Me :D

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] C SEC Agent [quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Sandtrap Then how come the rookie, AND Noble 6 are standing next to each other?[/quote] That is just Bungie giving us more (on top of an already huge pile of) hints.[/quote] Then how the hell could they be standing next to each other if they are the SAME PERSON?

[quote][b]Posted by:[/b] Cookies of joy Odsts are Marines before being an ODST. Silly. Rookie was a newly transferred Odst[/quote] ODSTs can come from any branch of the military, due to it being voluntary.

they could have sent back a pelican fro him or something, shot down the elites, fly to earth, give him medical treatment, then the odst time came and they were short on experienced members so he voluntered for one of the most important missions in the story line. bra mines possible