{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
12/22/2014 9:20:22 AM
10
There is no way that would work and it doesn't fit the story of the game. Why would Guardians fight each other to defend an enemy?! I get that PvP is supposed to be Guardians honing their skills sparring against each other, but this is ludicrous.
English
-
and by the why i mentioned the templar just to give an example, maybe it was a bad example but imagine someone else like the dead orbit guy in the tower or the FWC guy or any faction representative. and a choice to do the raid in the name of any faction. expand your imagination, this whole game that we enjoy came from ideas like this or better\worse.
-
I'm fine with things that actually make sense being added. There are no PvP raids in any game because they just don't make any real sense. And sometimes what we "want" as a community is pretty dumb. Anyone who thinks Sparrow racing is worth the effort for Bungie to make, isn't very smart. Why do all games need a crap racing simulator? Go play real racing games if you want that. You can hardly go one area to the next without pausing to load the next area the way it is. And most areas aren't designed for good travel routes anyway. The time they spend on such a thing could easily go to better things like actual new content, fixing bugs with raids, general game stability for most players, etc...
-
i respect what you said and well said, i just don't agree with you that it doesn't make sense where as you can see most of the people in the poll are between "agreed" and "mixed feelings". thank you for your post though and i agree with what you said except the part i mentioned above.
-
Looks like the large response is no. The best you can count for yes is currently 19%. Unsure doesn't count for yes or no, that's why it's separated. You made the poll and should understand that. So 81% don't think or can't clearly see a way it would work. Not combining to suit my side, just adding up the rest after the clear option of "yes". Again, there is no compelling argument for why or how this would actually work in a game, and the poll is showing that. Otherwise there would be more in favor of it, possibly including myself.
-
Currently the story is still in progress and we don't know much about it which gives bungie a chance to tweak it to serve a good purpose. with your logic now tell me what's the story behind the current PVP ? .. maybe i missed something. the factions are there and we don't know anything about it's stroy except very little, i think ideas like this in the start of the game could do something in the future of the game. thanks for the replay
-
Still wouldn't work. And you must have not read my earlier post. I already answered your question there.
-
Edited by Leomessi10: 12/22/2014 9:43:21 AMare you saying that only guardians honing their skills against each other is a story, is this your definition for a story ? i would expect nothing less from you since all your objection to the whole idea is "it won't work". thanks anyway.
-
For one thing, you haven't explained a way it would work either, so thanks for being insulting. Maybe I don't have an idea to make it work, because there isn't one. And you need more of a story to PvP than Guardians sparring? Why? Who cares? It's PvP. You don't need more story than that.
-
first of all i didn't mean to insult you and if you were insulted then i apologize, i was just criticizing your way of being somewhat negative instead of helping me building the idea, as a community we build together not alone and i would have appreciated some support in building the idea, i had no intentions to offend you my dear sir. and why not have a story for PvP ? .. and why would you assume that nobody cares ? .. i for one think a story or a semi story in the PvP could attract me more to the whole other side of the game. FWC was having issues with DO and this week the fires of war is lit between them and we spend a week or 2 fighting each other until the queen comes and end it .. i don't know could be fun don't you think ? :D
-
I guess but it doesn't make sense in the game story that exists already. Factions have nothing to do with Guardians sparring against each other so for Bungie to include them so heavily involved with PvP is a bad decision on the face of it. The Queen couldn't care less about Guardians fighting each other. She is a separate entity altogether. Factions should have had stories (which might have been cut) and picking Factions should have mattered. There should be plenty more story than there is. That's well documented, but I don't think PvP needs more story than sparring. The story should be added where it's important, in the story mode, patrols/bounties, factions.
